[B]Mcculloch Saws Which Is Better[/B]

[gunner1965]

Hello friends,
I have the following saws to look at and can only by one right now.
Which would be the better in your opinions for an all around felling saw (mainly Fir/Cedar/alder and Hemlock?

Super pro mac 610 w/20"
Promac 610 w/20"
Pro Mac 650 w/24"

All are near new condition

Thanks in advance
Gunner

 

[computeruser]

They all seem to be more or less the same saw, per Mike Acres' site. Looks like the Super Pro Mac 610 is the newest of the lot, that might be a factor worth considering.

 

[Butch(OH)]

Having spent much time with several 610 variants and limited time with a couple of 650s I see little to choose from in your list. The power differance is minimal by feel.The versions with a half wrap safety stop bar are older (I think) and short stop bar is less in the way during felling. I'd personaly go with the best condition vs price or one with a short safety bar unless I had to have the 24" bar. They aint as bad ole saw and shouldnt be much money unless NIB, remember the ear plugs.