Which electric saw to keep? 4.5hpMcCulloch or 3hpRemington?

[chainsaw2986]

Hi

We are cleaning out our garage and have two electric chainsaws. We don't think that we need two, so one has to go. Which one should we keep and which one is more valuable?

3hp Remington m30016aw 11.5amp
4.5hp McCulloch Medallion series em450s 14.5 amp

Both are made in the USA. Both are 16". I don't know which one is newer but they are likely 20+ years old. Does anyone know?

I imagine the 3hp would work safely on more 50ft extension cords due to lower amp rating. Does that matter?
Thanks

 

[ElevatorGuy]

I would trash them both lol.