Had my 440 up against a 2171

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
MNfarmer

MNfarmer

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 22, 2007
Messages
538
Location
Central MN
And kicked his butt!!! However... the owner of the 2171 said his chain wasn't very good and was some off breed of a safety chain. He did say mine cut faster, but my chain was razor sharp and I have my rakers filed down aways. Being the same sized saw and if they had comparable chains I would think they would be pretty close in performance. Nothing against the 2171.. seems like a really good saw, just some observations I made yesterday!! :rock:
 
ciscoguy01

ciscoguy01

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Oct 26, 2006
Messages
2,079
Location
'daks
Yip

And kicked his butt!!! However... the owner of the 2171 said his chain wasn't very good and was some off breed of a safety chain. He did say mine cut faster, but my chain was razor sharp and I have my rakers filed down aways. Being the same sized saw and if they had comparable chains I would think they would be pretty close in performance. Nothing against the 2171.. seems like a really good saw, just some observations I made yesterday!! :rock:

You'll hear a buncha crap from people that don't know squat, but I did the same to my buddy with his little 2171 also... They are nice saws, but they just don't cut like the stihls do bro... Rub it in his face every chance you get now...

:cheers: eh?
 
Austin1

Austin1

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Nov 9, 2006
Messages
3,133
Location
Calgary alberta Canada
And kicked his butt!!! However... the owner of the 2171 said his chain wasn't very good and was some off breed of a safety chain. He did say mine cut faster, but my chain was razor sharp and I have my rakers filed down aways. Being the same sized saw and if they had comparable chains I would think they would be pretty close in performance. Nothing against the 2171.. seems like a really good saw, just some observations I made yesterday!! :rock:
You take a nice honest approach to this I being more of a Jred fan see your point! I also believe in my own little mind that Stihl makes really good saw's so long as they are big saw's. The 440 460and up are all good saw's I had a 044 and in a way I wish I kept it. To be honest I think in the current crop of 70cc saws there is so little diff between them you would be splitting hairs. Off topic here I don't have a 026 or 260 but I have a real soft spot for them as they seam to go forever.
 
manual

manual

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
4,720
Location
Barton City Mi.
And kicked his butt!!! However... the owner of the 2171 said his chain wasn't very good and was some off breed of a safety chain. He did say mine cut faster, but my chain was razor sharp and I have my rakers filed down aways. Being the same sized saw and if they had comparable chains I would think they would be pretty close in performance. Nothing against the 2171.. seems like a really good saw, just some observations I made yesterday!! :rock:

A sharp chain is worth 3.9876454 X the HP...

Thanks Lakeside.
Thats the first thing that intered my mind.

LOL

Today I had a race with a Jonsered that had a dull safty chain on it....
and I won.........Go figure.
 
Woodie

Woodie

"Cap'n Bullcrap'n"
Joined
Aug 12, 2006
Messages
4,677
Location
SE Michigan
You'll hear a buncha crap from people that don't know squat, but I did the same to my buddy with his little 2171 also... They are nice saws, but they just don't cut like the stihls do bro... Rub it in his face every chance you get now...

:cheers: eh?

This post is both funny, and sad, at the same time.
 
manual

manual

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
4,720
Location
Barton City Mi.
You'll hear a buncha crap from people that don't know squat, but I did the same to my buddy with his little 2171 also... They are nice saws, but they just don't cut like the stihls do bro... Rub it in his face every chance you get now...

:cheers: eh?

This post is both funny, and sad, at the same time.

Yeah I like the part where he said the 2171 is little.
Maybe he don't know squat.
side by side the 2171 is bigger.

Hey ciscodude stop reefing on those huskys, it's not a Stihl. you don't have to work as hard, Let it do the cutting for ya.
 
Austin1

Austin1

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Nov 9, 2006
Messages
3,133
Location
Calgary alberta Canada
Yep, little point in comparing saws in the cut, unless you use the same chain on both - that is why the jury is still out on the New 346xp vs the 5100 over here - Witchys problems keep me from cutting, and testing........:censored:
I hope she will be feeling better soon I can't imagine the stress you are going through By nature I am a worry wort.
 

Latest posts

Top