Another cord thread...MN legal definition...arrgh

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Steve NW WI

Steve NW WI

Unwanted Riff Raff.
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
7,880
Location
Wisconsin
I was looking for a "thrown cord" volume on MN's Dept of commerce web site for another thread, and I got to reading the fine print. It turns out that those oddball Swedes, Irishmen, Finns and Germans over in MN have decided that 120 cu ft of split and stacked wood is a cord.

From this page: http://mn.gov/commerce/weights-and-measures/images/BuyingFirewood.pdf

Here's the quote, reference to MN statute given at the end:

What is a cord?

A cord has a specific legal definition in Minnesota:

• One cord is 128 cubic feet in four foot lengths.

• If the wood is sawed, a cord is 110 cubic feet when
ranked, or 160 cubic feet when thrown loosely into a
truck.

• If the wood is sawed and split, a cord is 120 cubic feet
when ranked, and 175 cubic feet when thrown loosely
into a truck. (Minnesota Statutes, Section 239.33)

So, by their definition, 128 ft³ (btw, hold down the ALT key and type 0179 on your number pad to get the ³ symbol, something else I learned today) of 4' logs, when cut and stacked will shrink to 110 ft³, then grow to 120 ft³ when split and restacked. Loose rounds are 160ft³, and loose splits are 175ft³ to make a cord.

WTF? If government can't even have a standard "standard", I'm giving up on straightening out wayward measurers. WI by the way, beleives in 128 ft³, "well ranked and stowed" - WI Statutes 98.02(2) Link here: Wisconsin Legislature: 98.02(2)
 
Last edited:
turnkey4099
Joined
Feb 27, 2002
Messages
20,060
Location
se washington
I was looking for a "thrown cord" volume on MN's Dept of commerce web site for another thread, and I got to reading the fine print. It turns out that those oddball Swedes, Irishmen, Finns and Germans over in MN have decided that 120 cu ft of split and stacked wood is a cord.

From this page: http://mn.gov/commerce/weights-and-measures/images/BuyingFirewood.pdf

Here's the quote, reference to MN statute given at the end:

What is a cord?

A cord has a specific legal definition in Minnesota:

• One cord is 128 cubic feet in four foot lengths.

• If the wood is sawed, a cord is 110 cubic feet when
ranked, or 160 cubic feet when thrown loosely into a
truck.

• If the wood is sawed and split, a cord is 120 cubic feet
when ranked, and 175 cubic feet when thrown loosely
into a truck. (Minnesota Statutes, Section 239.33)

<snip>

WTF!! is right. They even have the adjustments from whole to cut/split/stacked bassackwards. The amount of _actual_ wood in a given size pile _shrinks_ with each step in processing. Thus they should be _adding_ cu ft over the "4' lenght cord" for cut and and again for cut/split if they want to make addustments. In reality they shouldn't be screwing with an industry standard at all.

Harry K
 
les-or-more

les-or-more

I was here but now im gone!
Staff member
Moderator
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
24,783
Location
lisbon ny
WTF!! is right. They even have the adjustments from whole to cut/split/stacked bassackwards. The amount of _actual_ wood in a given size pile _shrinks_ with each step in processing. Thus they should be _adding_ cu ft over the "4' lenght cord" for cut and and again for cut/split if they want to make addustments. In reality they shouldn't be screwing with an industry standard at all.

Harry K

Well look at that the "industry standard" isn't standard either. The ton is looking better all the time now isn't it?
 
Steve NW WI

Steve NW WI

Unwanted Riff Raff.
Joined
Jan 10, 2009
Messages
7,880
Location
Wisconsin
Well look at that the "industry standard" isn't standard either. The ton is looking better all the time now isn't it?

That'd work...IF the standard was tons on a dry matter basis. Gotta take moisture outta the equation. You'd need a certifiable method of measuring moisture content then.

It's industry standard in grain selling, so its workable. Bushels of grain are actually sold by weigt not volume.
 
les-or-more

les-or-more

I was here but now im gone!
Staff member
Moderator
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
24,783
Location
lisbon ny
That'd work...IF the standard was tons on a dry matter basis. Gotta take moisture outta the equation. You'd need a certifiable method of measuring moisture content then.

It's industry standard in grain selling, so its workable. Bushels of grain are actually sold by weigt not volume.

It would get rid of the difference in BTU's between species of tree, and end all the silly arguing over length of cut and what people call it.
 
Hedgerow

Hedgerow

HACK
Joined
Dec 20, 2010
Messages
15,356
Location
Carthage, MO
That'd work...IF the standard was tons on a dry matter basis. Gotta take moisture outta the equation. You'd need a certifiable method of measuring moisture content then.

It's industry standard in grain selling, so its workable. Bushels of grain are actually sold by weigt not volume.

You're right... Then all firewood would be equal on a dollar per btu unit, no matter what the variety... :rock:
 
turnkey4099
Joined
Feb 27, 2002
Messages
20,060
Location
se washington
wood being sold by the btu like natural gas/propane by the cubic foot/gallon?? now this is something to thunk about.....

??? Nope, in your example one is being sold by volumn (gas/propane) the other by btu (wood).

What it comes down to is cord is a defined volumn amount. What is in that volume has to be specified by the producer. Same as a galloon of paint says nothing about the quality or a 'bushel" says nothing about what kind of grain or quality thereof is in it.

E.g. I have a cord of seasoned oak here at $x. That pile over there is pine priced as $y per cord.

Les or more seems to be trying to troll again.

Harry K
 
turnkey4099
Joined
Feb 27, 2002
Messages
20,060
Location
se washington
That'd work...IF the standard was tons on a dry matter basis. Gotta take moisture outta the equation. You'd need a certifiable method of measuring moisture content then.

It's industry standard in grain selling, so its workable. Bushels of grain are actually sold by weigt not volume.

This old farm boy learned something. I thought you were full of it but your are correct. Seems thing changed some since I was back on the farm in the mid 50s.

Harry K
 
TreePointer

TreePointer

Addicted to ArboristSite
AS Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2008
Messages
3,967
Location
Western PA
I wonder what happened to make the definition ridiculous. Sometimes govt. officials make compliance so difficult so as to squeeze out the little guy or reduce an undesirable industry. Or maybe some state representative's MIL complained after she thought she was shorted on firewood delivery.

Absurd.
 

Latest posts

Top