Best mini for the money on these two

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Jace

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
277
Reaction score
10
Location
Midwest
650
dw1.jpg
dw2.jpg dw3.jpg






Ive never owned a mini skidsteer, have rented them a couple times. Done some thread reading, and I gather the majority of tree guys lean toward the sk650, although any mini is better than no mini at all...
Anyway, Im trying to choose between a 2002 tx420 1400 hours thats a little rough, but owner says doesnt burn any oil, motor nvr been rebuilt, tracks almost new. Says its ready to go...$5500. Im concerned I might have to be putting money into it though.
Or a 2009 sk650, same hours but not so beat up, runs good, for $12,000.
I can stretch the finances and get the 650, just not sure i want to, because I could use the price difference money and also get a dump bed trailer....
I do have a 16' dump truck that either will load thru the back doors. Of course the 650 would reach a little higher.
Anyway, just wondering which one is the best deal?
Thanks for any thoughts or advice.


425


t1.png t2.png t3.png t4.png
 
id get the dingo for now until u can afford a real nice machine and a dump trailer is really nice haha
 
I'm partial to the DW since I'm the happy owner of a sk650. The model that has replaced it (750) is a considerably more expensive machine.
No stand on operator platform on that dingo?
Does the sk650 come with a bucket and/or grapple?
 
I just bought a dw sk750 and I love the machine stand on platform and lifts anything I need it to, and then some with an extra guy on the back. but I try not to do that to much.
 
I'd go with dingo. Based on price. Get it, use it, make some money. I bought the same model earlier this summer. 02 tx420 ( hour meter was broke but in sure hours were high). It started burning oil a few months later. Brand New motor with install is roughly $3k. You would still be well under $12k & have a little cash for that dump trailer. And that's IF your motor starts to burn oil or anything.
 
Well, I decided to go ahead and go with the dingo and got it bought this afternoon. Didn't want to wait and loose out. I gave 5600 for it, it came with a snowplow, a set of forks, a bucket, a 3-tine ripper, and two different ride-on plates.
One lift cylinder is slowly drip-leaking.

Seems to run and work fine tho, I used it in a gravel pile some.

I figure if it'll get me by for 1-2 years, and if it doesn't get much into my wallet w breakdowns, I can keep watch for another good deal on a sk650, buy it, and sell the dingo.

I rent a full size bobcat when I need to from a friend for $25 an hour, so if I need something more powerful now and then...

Sure woulda like to have had the big 650 though...in a yr or two.

Thanks for all the help & advice.


Treecutterjr, u got the log grapple for yours?
 
Jace if you own that thing outright and it last you 2 years even if you put 3k back into it your gonna be ahead. Fix all the little bugs and run it till its a ball of rust. I dont think the 650 is gonna be worth the extra coin endless you can get a deal.
 
I'm very happy with my toro. Not a fan of Kohler. Seems like something is always failing on them and I've somehow got 3. What engine ?
 
Congrats on getting a mini, it will pay for itself quickly. Get a grapple as soon as you can too. I used forks for a year before getting my bmg... I shouldn't have waited.

8677efc794968d01f985b12b3a709a47.jpg

Only gate was on the backside...in the woods. So I just reached over the fence.

0b7af5a2197c58905f63a1c74cacbca1.jpg

Chestnut oak log, about 9' long x 20" diameter

28843d4851945db9a74175f16fc48e3b.jpg

Half hour and I'm headed home.
 
Sure looks handy. I'm thinkin for the meantime, Im going to try to use my log tongs. I may have to get off the mini every time I hook them arund a log, but thatll take all of about 30 seconds, and Im not ready to shell out over 2g on a bmg just yet, if I can hook a short chain to my log tong and serve the same purpose. Not nearly as smooth no doubt. Hardest part will be to get hooked exactly in the center to load w/out one end tipping up or down. Practically impossible w/out having another guy balance one side when loading.
I cant find a used bmg on the internet anywhere. Guess a guys gotta go new, and if he did find a used one he'd spend probly just pennys less.
Wheres the cheapest place to buy the bmg new?
 
I got mine from Top notch equipment, with all the attachment

http://www.topnotchequipment.com/catalog_items.asp?cat=8409-100656

Another online dealer is here:
http://compactequipmentstore.com/collections/branch-manager-attachments-1

Both are very good guys to work with.

Tongs will work for wood. Cinching rope around brush piles, to drag it, will work. 30 seconds doesn't seem a lot, but it adds up. Once you do get a grapple you will be amazed at how fast it is.

Video loading wood with a grapple


There are few other videos using the grapple on my youtube channels too.
 
I just bought a dw sk750 and I love the machine stand on platform and lifts anything I need it to, and then some with an extra guy on the back. but I try not to do that to much.
I just messaged you about selling my vermeer but then seen this. Congrats on your mini you will love it!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top