The truth is, octane doesn't produce any power, it's just something that regulates detonation. How much octane is needed depends on a lot of factors, but compression and engine type are two of them. 2 Cycle engines tend to have higher compression than 4 strokes, but not always.
I'll tell you what is a waste is running AV gas in a saw or 2 cycle motorcycle. These engines rev way higher than any airplane and AV gas just isn't formulated for high RPM's. Running AV gas at 10k+ RPM will cost you some power for sure. How much of a loss is subjective. Some people probably wouldn't even notice it.
Here's what I suggest:
- Race Gas: Not all race gas is the same. If you have access to race gas I would suggest you call the mfg and ask them what they would recommend for a chainsaw. I use VP Racing Fuels C12 in my saws. This gas is an excellent fuel that's perfectly blended for small CC, hi RPM 2 cycle engines. I also only run Stihl Ultra for my mix. C12 is great because it has a little bit of lead in it which is really good for lubrication. AV gas has lead in it too, but a lot more than C12.
- 50 Fuel: These people make a premixed gas specifically for chainsaws and small 2 cycle motors. I tested some of their gas and I have to tell you, I think it was the best out of all the fuels I tested. If you can get it, it's well worth it. You'll be able to get it from their website at www.50fuels.com
- Pump Gas: Ya know, sometimes ya just have to run it. Try to stay away from pump gas that has ethanol in it. Ethanol=BAD. It's abrasive, it sucks in water out of the air, and it causes your gas to go bad very quickly, gumming up everything it touches. Pump gas is the lowest quality fuel a refinery makes and shouldn't even be used in your car. If you have to use pump gas, don't by the cheap stuff. Get a quality mfg and buy their mid to hi grades. Premium isn't necessary btw. Anything over 89 octane is fine.
Quit thinking octane though. It's the blend that matters, not the octane. If you do end up with a higher octane fuel, you'll probably have to adjust the carb a little bit and possibly the timing. Bring it to the shop if you're not comfortable tinkering with those settings. (Or ask here. Somebody will point you in the right direction.)
I like your thinking, minus the ethonol part, and pump gas being bad, the idea that higher octain fuels burn cooler being a good reason to use them is nonsense, mixture and O2 content of the fuel have FAR more drastic of an effect on temp than octain, and the lower octain fuel is not burning hotter, but faster, and therefore energy is being converted into heat rather than downward movement of the piston, taking power (torque) with it, without timming adjustments a higher octane fuel will lose power.
Race gas is made for a reason, a average passenger car has about a 8:1 compression ratio, and a drag car has upward of 12+:1 that added compression ratio puts a greater stress on the fuel to ignite due to compression, like a diesel, before TDC (knocking) to combat this you need a higher octain fuel that will resist detonation, but you also have to drasticly change not only the base timming but the advance curve and ammount, because the fuel burns slower the spark has to occur earlier in the cycle, so that you reach peak combustion pressure at or slighly behind TDC.
On a small 2 stroke engine, like a saw, ignition timming is key to making power, if your fuel is only 3/4 burned when the piston moves past the point of covering the exhaust port, than you have lost potential energy to heat leaving the exhaust unburnt. without advancing the timming a higher octaine fuel is going to slow the burn down to that point.
sorry for the rambling on.........edited for calrity...
Last edited: