Whats wrong With this oak.....

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

l2edneck

Small Job Specialist
Joined
Jun 16, 2006
Messages
999
Reaction score
214
Location
Clearwater,Fl
I've noticed it for years and finally stopped to take a pic.I didnt know where to post this so this might be the best.This is where i see most the gurus.

Bulgingoak1resized.jpg

Bulgingoak2resized.jpg

Bulgingoak3resized.jpg

Bulgingoak4resized.jpg



I'm eager to learn what this is.Personally is weird to me.Its on a canal in a field.Im thinkin maybe when they dozed the lot they damaged it.

Any input is a bonus.TY:biggrinbounce2:
 
TreeCo said:
I may not be right.

It may be the deformities are caused by a canker disease.
Good call, Barber; those are burls, cause unknown. It is rampant callusing; whether caused by insect or disease or humans or genetics--likely some combination.

Where in Clearwater is it? I'd like to check it next time down.

• Abnormal swelling of plant tissues--“galls” —in leaves and twigs are seldom a health concern, and never a structural concern. Galls or "burls" in stems can be inspected for hollow sounds, holes, weeping, and “frass”—material produced by insects. If they are free of these aggravating factors, the growths may be a structural benefit.
• Sour-smelling fluid oozing from a stem may attract insects and cause concern among tree owners, but it rarely indicates a safety issue. This slime flux may need treatment for the long-term health of the tree, but not because of immediate risk concerns. The bacteria that cause the sap to ferment and ooze down the trunk also inhibit the growth of decay fungi, so the ooze is not bad news for the structure of the tree. Bacterial infection is not a structural defect.
• Trees respond to wounds by forming callus or “scar” tissue around them. Callus is undifferentiated, like human stem cells. In time this tissue can become differentiated, or specialized, as it develops into woundwood. As the hardening substance called lignin is deposited, the lignified woundwood can be much stronger than normal wood. Therefore, even while decay is spreading on the inside of a tree, the development of woundwood can compensate for some of that loss of strength.
 
Its actually in Largo.

Just west of starkey rd on East Bay drive.South side of road.If yer gonna be in town just gimme a call ill be happy to tell ya or show ya.
 
l2edneck said:
Just west of starkey rd on East Bay drive.South side of road.If yer gonna be in town just gimme a call ill be happy to tell ya or show ya.
Cool, that's near my mom's place. I plan to be down halloween weekend. If you can note other arboreal oddities, we could do a little tour.:rockn:

I'm trying to talk to the owners of the Kapok Tree on mcmullen booth about caring for it, but they blow me off every time, while letting their landscrapers do their things to it. drives me nuts.:bang: .
 
Way huge burl.

I'm impressed, funny how the largest burls are always close to ground not like 50' up.

Now check this out, the burls seem to always be on the sunnier side.

I noticed that one doesn't go all the way around so does it face the sunniest side?
 
Hi Ekka. Just for interests sake I was at my parents place for dinner tonight and they have a rather large Manitoba Maple (Acer negundo) aprox. 60"DBH that has a huge burl about three feet off the ground that goes almost all of the way around the tree and it is predominantly north facing.

Sorry for no pictures I'm going to try to figure out how to do that really soon. Have mercy I'm new to this whole computer thing.

Also 12edneck what's with the ropes in the pictures
 
Are you sure that's an oak and not a mulberry? I've seen many mulberries like that, but never an oak. At least not that big on an oak. :dizzy:
 
Its definitly an oak

and the main part faces north.Seems to be even sun both sides.Those arent ropes they are old cable,phone wires that the tree grew around till it boke them off.
 
Looks like a water oak Quercus aqua mineralie. Just kidding. Biggest burl i ever seen.
 
Yeah I've never seen a correlation between compass points or sun exposure and burls, and I've seen a lot of burls.
 
l2edneck said:
Those arent ropes they are old cable,phone wires that the tree grew around till it boke them off.

I wonder whether any of those wires are copper that's poisoning the tree and helping cause those structures...?
 
treeseer said:
Yeah I've never seen a correlation between compass points or sun exposure and burls, and I've seen a lot of burls.

Over here I rarely if ever see a burl on the shadow (south) side of the tree, they're nearly always on the east/north/west side ... just an observation but incredibly consistent one.
 
Back
Top