hickory? tree Id

[Adkpk]

The first two pics are of one tree and the third is another. I think these are hickory but I am not sure. I haven't seen them with the leaves. Anybody?

My guess on this tree is poplar. Anybody?

 

[Grace Tree]

Maybe a Shellbark Hickory. If you can, grab some leaves that seem to be common around the base of the tree and take a pic of those. If it's shellbark the leaves will be big and flat with toothed edges.
Phil

 

[trimmmed]

http://www.acris.nynhp.org/guide.php?id=9119

If it's a shellbark, it appears they are rare in NY. Cool looking tree!

 

[Kneejerk Bombas]

I would have guessed the first two were Black Cherry, and the third was a dead Pine or maybe a Poplar.

 

[johnha]

Since its without leaves, can you post a pic of a branch/stems?

 

[Adkpk]

I am going back up this weekend, I will look more closely for nuts, dead leaves or any hints that will help. The branches don't start for like 40' or more.

Trimmmed, great website, thanks.

 

[Husky137]

First two pics look like cherry to me.

 

[appalachianarbo]

Pictures from further away looking straight at the trunk would give us a better idea of the actual bark pattern. Those shots straight up the trunk kind of distort the patterns. I agree, the first three look like black cherry.

 

[lorax]

Tree ID

They look like Black cherrys to me and the other looks like a dead cotton wood or pine. Where in NY are they?

 

[Adkpk]

They look like Black cherrys to me and the other looks like a dead cotton wood or pine. Where in NY are they?

Central Catskills.