Stihl chain VS oregon and others.
- Thread starter jdhacker
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
How much chain do you go through in a year? If you only use four or five chains a year Stihl is probably your best bet.
If you use a lot of chains the added price of Stihl over Oregon comes into play. I've always thought that Stihl makes the best chains, period. But they're not enough better than Oregon to justify a lot of additional cost that heavy chain usage brings.
Our bean counter kept track of chain costs over two years. She gets bored sometimes and does things like that. On a cost per hour of operation the Oregon, and buying the chain in reels, and spinning our own loops, was a better deal for us. The Stihl lasted a little longer but not enough longer to make it worthwhile.
That being said, if I was a firewood cutter and didn't use a lot of chains and didn't have to worry about profits and wanted the best...I'd get Stihl.
I cut firewood as a side job, most of the time im cutting logged tops, so I do go through a few chains. im sure if I averaged out chain cost per how many loads of wood I can cut with a chain would be very low. But if Oregon is close I would proly switch.
Only way to tell for sure is to try a few brands, side-by- side if you can, and see what works for you.
Worst thing that will happen is you will find you have a first choice and a second choice.
Philbert
Worst thing that will happen is you will find you have a first choice and a second choice.
Philbert
KenJax Tree
Terraphobic
I like Oregon and Stihl for chisel chain but semi-chisel i only buy Stihl RM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
pops21
Addicted to ArboristSite
Semi chisel will extend your cutting time between sharpenings. The speed difference between chisel and semi chisel is minimal too. So in the end you get more bang for your buck. For me I try to get stihl when I have the $$.
windthrown
361 Junkie
I only use Stihl and Carlton chain myself. Stihl is the best, Carlton is a close second. I find Oregon chain to be too soft. If you are buying from Baileys, they sell WoodlandPro, which is re-branded Carlton. Carlton makes good semi-chisel chain in non-safety.
Thanks for the heads up! this is why I love this place.
MS460WOODCHUCK
Addicted to ArboristSite
I like to run the woodland pro or carlton myself. The stihl chain is good but more $$$ and the Oregon is good chain but soft IMO.
I like Stihl RS, but I mostly cut clean wood. In clean wood it cuts noticeably faster than RM. In dirty or dry wood, RM may be the better choice.
If the bean counter factored in "lost labor", the Stihl chain would likely have been the best buy (since he said it lasted longer). It doesn't take much lost labor to buy a chain. I used to audit "Bean Counters", I'm a retired Certified Fraud Examiner.
For my cutting time, I will stick with Stihl chain. (I have used Woodland Pro rip chain, but never any Carlton). However, if Windthrown uses it I would not hesitate to use that also.
If the bean counter factored in "lost labor", the Stihl chain would likely have been the best buy (since he said it lasted longer). It doesn't take much lost labor to buy a chain. I used to audit "Bean Counters", I'm a retired Certified Fraud Examiner.
For my cutting time, I will stick with Stihl chain. (I have used Woodland Pro rip chain, but never any Carlton). However, if Windthrown uses it I would not hesitate to use that also.
+1 on what widthrown says....l think carton is the best value and most overlooked chain option. Stihl is best if money aint in the equation and oregon is still a great chain, l just brought 2 rolls of 72apx and 72dpx cause l got them at a good price from weedeaterman (Randy). Carlton though is hard metal, its nice chain to sharpen, holds its edge well and is rebranded as woodland pro as baileys 'in house' chain at very reasonable prices. Also Gologit makes a good point, when l only went through say 5 chains a year l was very happy running stihl...it made sense....now having over 10 saw in operation cost is a big factor and l now only use minimal stihl chain as others cost alot less and cut as good or better. Also it seems carlton is not as big on big bumper ramps in thier chain....l hate them ramps..
M
moody
Guest
Stihl makes the best chain. It's consistent out of the package and I find that when I hit nails or fence I can usually salvage the loop. But you pay for quality. A 84 DL loop of RM cost me about $32 oregon lgx runs around $25. As Bob said if you're not using 10+ loops a year buy Stihl. But the more you use the better your wallet will like oregon
That's high for stihl. I've bought it by reels and stihl was the better deal until it went up $50 more than it was. It's now $100 more than Oregon and not worth the 30% increase in price. Milling requires lots more touch ups than falling and bucking clean wood. Sometimes I swap saws after one cut so I don't have to sharpen. I can sharpen Rm to cut right with rs in clean wood so all my chisel chain is square filed and round is semi chisel.
Twisted Priorities
ArboristSite Operative
I only use Stihl chain. It holds an edge longer than other brands ( better heat treating process ),Oregon chain does seem to be softer. I've purchased chain while at the cottage from Home Depot, Walmart and Tractor Supply over the years, they never last. I should just drive the extra hour to get the good stuff.
A couple local Stihl dealers will sell damaged loops of chain ( box crushed or torn ) at 1/2 price because they can't display it. Hey, it works for me.
A couple local Stihl dealers will sell damaged loops of chain ( box crushed or torn ) at 1/2 price because they can't display it. Hey, it works for me.
KenJax Tree
Terraphobic
Walmart,HD,TSC are selling the junk Vanguard safety chain.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
sunfish
Fish Head
MGlazier28
ArboristSite Member
Hard to go wrong with either still, Oregon, or Carlton/woodland pro. I've run all three, very little if any difference in cut speed between them (assuming all properly filed). I run mostly carlton on my personal saws. . .but I keep a loop or two of stihl ps3 for my TH saw (3/8lp).
Trx250r180
Saw polisher
i have both stihl and oregon ,i think i can almost get a sharper edge on my stihl square chisel ,but both cut wood fine and both go dull when my bar tip hits the ground
I keep telling my friend next door who bought my 441 that you have to keep the chain saw work and farming SEPARATE!!!!!!
