Tree ID pls

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Eagleknight

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
104
Reaction score
241
Location
Troy, OH
Not sure what these two are. I am thinking both are bitternut hickory.
189bd988fafd41104d7f86812e518982.jpg
77b5eb2bf13a862aee81982c788cb3d7.jpg
 
White walnut I think for the first one.
Smells just like hickory when cutting and burning it.

Beech I think for the second.
 
Bitternut normally has a bigger darker center than that one shows unless it is pretty small. Hard to give it scale from your pic. Here are 2 pics of bitternut from our area.

MVC-001S_4.JPG


MVC-001S_3.JPG


Your second pic is definitely not bitternut. I'm not seeing it as Beech or hackberry either.
 
Bitternut normally has a bigger darker center than that one shows unless it is pretty small. Hard to give it scale from your pic. Here are 2 pics of bitternut from our area.

MVC-001S_4.JPG


MVC-001S_3.JPG


Your second pic is definitely not bitternut. I'm not seeing it as Beech or hackberry either.

Bitternut Hickory nuts are very distictive and a LOT different than Mockernut. These were what the nuts looked like around the tree shown in my post. Mockernut has a rougher bark from what I have found.

th
 
I am thinking both are Hackberry. First pic from the trunk, more mature. Second pic from a limb higher up.
 
If the wood really stinks, then it's Ohio Buckeye. And if it doesn't, then hackberry.
And I'm an OSU fan too, so don't go thinkin' otherwise! :happy: Yes, Ohio Buckeye has a REALLY bad stench....
 
In over 40 years of cutting I've never come across a hackberry tree with a dark center that big. The are all white around here. That and the cambium area doesn't have that much tan/brown showing. When you break the rough outer bark it is not that brown either. Here are a couple pics of hackberry from my burn pile.

MVC-004S_12.JPG


10 inch round

MVC-005S_10.JPG


12 inch dry rounds

MVC-003S_17.JPG


Dry round with bark cut with hatchet. Note the dull gray to white color.

MVC-004S_13.JPG


Close to 4 ft diameter hackberry, see the hatchet?

MVC-005S_12.JPG


MVC-006S_7.JPG


Bark does not have the brown inclusions like his first pic. I scraped some fresh off and even it has more gray and white in it.

I have a couple buckeye trees here but can't say that I've ever cut any of it to verify. I n both of your pics that bark looks WAY too smooth to be like ANY hackberry I've ever cut.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top