ID?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

djg james

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Feb 25, 2020
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
13,852
Location
IL
I've got one for you that I ran across recently. At first I thought it might be Ash because it had a slightly criss-cross pattern on it's bark. It didn't have the musty smell of Ash and it split real easy and clean like Soft Maple. Not stringy and light weight too.

IMG_0997.jpg
 
It might be, but the Bradford Pear I've cut turns (oxidizes?) a brownish-red. Plus I remember it splinters a lot.

All I had was the log. Oh well, I thought it might jog someone's memory.
 
Kinda looks like Callery (Bradford) Pear bark. The wood certainly splits easily. :laughing:

Without twigs, branching, and tree shape, a chunk of wood isn't too much to ID a tree with. Leaves and buds, as well as flower parts are always a big help, too.
Bradford pear green is heavy. He said it was light. Bark isn't even one to BP.
 
He didn't say the tree was alive.
Or when that picture was taken. Coulda been fresh cut in January at -6°.

Until you know, you can't be sure.

I'll certainly concede callery pear tends to be heavy when green. The appearance of the bark is still quite eligible for pear, from my experience.
 
It looks like kinda like Norway maple to me and I have split some where the rounds were relatively light. Maple’s usually have a earthy sweet smell to them and a certain sheen to the fresh split pieces. I can’t really tell from the pictures but does it have a maply smell?
 
He didn't say the tree was alive.
Or when that picture was taken. Coulda been fresh cut in January at -6°.

Until you know, you can't be sure.

I'll certainly concede callery pear tends to be heavy when green. The appearance of the bark is still quite eligible for pear, from my experience.
I guess I should have provided more information. I cut at an arborist's log yard and this was brought in (just cut) within the last month. I get Bradford Pear's bark mixed up all the time; sometimes I mistake it for Oak (lol). In my limited experience, it just didn't split like BP. Nor did it look like it on the inside either.
 
It looks like kinda like Norway maple to me and I have split some where the rounds were relatively light. Maple’s usually have a earthy sweet smell to them and a certain sheen to the fresh split pieces. I can’t really tell from the pictures but does it have a maply smell?
I'm beginning to think it may be some type of Maple. I split Soft Maple (silver?) and I love to split it. Only had to let the splitter's wedge go in a couple inches and it was split. This wood split almost the same. Didn't notice the smell. I'll check tomorrow.
 
I think it's Ash.
No, that's what I thought at first, too. But it 1) doesn't smell like Ash, 2) split way too easy, 3) wasn't stringy, 4) was light in weight, not heavy like Ash and 5) the grain doesn't look anything like Ash. I've cut a fair amount of Ash firewood and this is definitely not it.
 
I'm beginning to think it may be some type of Maple. I split Soft Maple (silver?) and I love to split it. Only had to let the splitter's wedge go in a couple inches and it was split. This wood split almost the same. Didn't notice the smell. I'll check tomorrow.
it's 100% not silver maple. for sure. silver maple bark is totaly different. when it's small it will be mostly smooth with some long cracks in the bark, and when big the bark forms big almost flakey strips, kind of like white oak, but not really

norway maple is the only maple with crisscrossed bark like that. if it's a maple, it's norway. if it's not a maple then the other things that looks similar to that are hickory, ash, tulip poplar, but i don't think it's any of them. hickory and ask have much lighter sapwood and much darker heart wood. tulip poplar has tints of green and purple.
 
it's 100% not silver maple. for sure. silver maple bark is totaly different. when it's small it will be mostly smooth with some long cracks in the bark, and when big the bark forms big almost flakey strips, kind of like white oak, but not really

norway maple is the only maple with crisscrossed bark like that. if it's a maple, it's norway. if it's not a maple then the other things that looks similar to that are hickory, ash, tulip poplar, but i don't think it's any of them. hickory and ask have much lighter sapwood and much darker heart wood. tulip poplar has tints of green and purple.
Yes, it's not Silver Maple. I split some along side this mystery wood and the Maple has a darker sections on the grain. Still white, but dark patches.

Not Hickory or Ash; not the right smell of either, nor weight or lack of stringyness.

No green/purple so probably not tulip poplar.
 
Back
Top