Upper Michigan (UP) two saw plan

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
johnsayen

johnsayen

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Nov 9, 2020
Messages
211
Location
Upper Michigan
I am not sure your impression is correct, brand loyalty is rather regional. Guessing I'd say the site is likely 40% stihl 40% husky 5% echo 5% poulan and 10% other.

.... maybe there is a poll thread around?
Oh I wasn’t referring to the site, they had mentioned that my region was mostly huskys in a different post.
 
AK Steve

AK Steve

ArboristSite Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
62
I grew up in Keweenaw County. We logged and cut plenty of firewood. I'd get a 562 Xp as a firewood saw. Frankly big firewood is more trouble than it's worth.
 
sled_22

sled_22

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Oct 22, 2020
Messages
163
Location
WI
Another vote for the 462, That will also likely be my next saw. It will be years before the 400 is here I bet so take that off the list. The 500 looks impressive but I don’t think I’d pass on the 462.
A little bird told me Stihl US is releasing the 400 in January 2021.
 
newforest

newforest

ArboristSite Operative
AS Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
260
Location
Michigan
A single 60cc saw would be fine for the wood sizes you will cut. But a 2 saw plan is better for when the saws get older, and you can pinch a brand new saw as easily as any other. Unless I am just going fishing, I always take 2 saws with me in the woods.

So I would go with a 16” 50cc saw and a 20”’60 or 70cc model. For me on the Svedish saws that’s a 550XP & a 562XP.

If you only need 5 cords a year I wouldn’t fool with trying to move 30” rounds around if you have access to enough tops anyway, particularly if that is 5 face cords for a part time heating application. For 5 full cords to heat a home 24/7 maybe I would tackle some of the bigger blocks. Overall I prefer to haul home a load of poles as thick and long as I can move in the woods and then cut them up on a sawbuck as close as I can get a vehicle to where they will be burned.

There is a great combo shop in Wakefield that I hope keeps going. Pickford has a good combination shop too. The Stihl outfit in Ishpeming has impressed me with the parts supply they keep on hand (far better than yr average Ace Hardware) but that’s all I have ever stopped in for.
 
johnsayen

johnsayen

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Nov 9, 2020
Messages
211
Location
Upper Michigan
Thank you - I should have specified it's 5 full cords - I still don't think I'll mess with 30 inchers as it just doesn't seem worth it. Since I have the 261 I am eyeing both the 400c and the 462c.
 
ElevatorGuy

ElevatorGuy

Yota’s and John Deere green!
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Sep 2, 2020
Messages
2,031
Location
Maryland
I’m curious about the 400c. First thing I’ve noticed is the international site lists it as more powerful than a ms362 yet lists the bars as 16,18 or 20. I wonder why that is because you can run the 25 on the 362. That isn’t ideal in hardwood but it works. I looked at the 462 last weekend, sure looks sweet wearing the 28” light bar. For me the 462 with a 28 would do anything I would touch and will scream with the 20.
 
Lionsfan

Lionsfan

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Aug 11, 2019
Messages
1,801
Location
Cheboygan, MI
I’m curious about the 400c. First thing I’ve noticed is the international site lists it as more powerful than a ms362 yet lists the bars as 16,18 or 20. I wonder why that is because you can run the 25 on the 362. That isn’t ideal in hardwood but it works. I looked at the 462 last weekend, sure looks sweet wearing the 28” light bar. For me the 462 with a 28 would do anything I would touch and will scream with the 20.

I was surprised to see a 462 setting on the bottom shelf at our local Ace hardware. I picked it up and played with it for a couple minutes. Now cheap, but it's certainly light for it's size and seems well designed.
 
ElevatorGuy

ElevatorGuy

Yota’s and John Deere green!
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Sep 2, 2020
Messages
2,031
Location
Maryland
I was surprised to see a 462 setting on the bottom shelf at our local Ace hardware. I picked it up and played with it for a couple minutes. Now cheap, but it's certainly light for it's size and seems well designed.
Ace hears only sells echo. I’d hit my dealer where my jd tractor and my other stihl saw came from. Good old place, been around a long time.
 
lone wolf
Joined
Oct 5, 2009
Messages
71,961
Location
Prowling The Pine Barrens
So it’s mostly hardwood that we harvest up here for firewood, with the occasional cedar for kindling. A lot of it is dead or near dead at the time of felling. Not always but a lot of the time. I’m decently experienced at bucking but have very little experience felling. Been watching a lot of training and reading a book, but also going to ask someone in person for some felling training.
Started with an ms251, upgraded to a 261, and am now contemplating a second saw as I intend to process 5 cord a year in firewood for our new wood burner.

most people have recommend a 462, one person a 400, and another a 500i.
I have a 16” bar on my 261(also have a 20 for it, might get an 18 too) and intend to run a 20” on the second saw (with either a 25 or 28 second bar).

I don’t want to suffer from the upgrade game a second time, hopefully a buy once cry once sort of thing.
Which second saw would you recommend given all of the above?
A 241 c and an 044 .
 
johnsayen

johnsayen

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Nov 9, 2020
Messages
211
Location
Upper Michigan
I’m curious about the 400c. First thing I’ve noticed is the international site lists it as more powerful than a ms362 yet lists the bars as 16,18 or 20. I wonder why that is because you can run the 25 on the 362. That isn’t ideal in hardwood but it works. I looked at the 462 last weekend, sure looks sweet wearing the 28” light bar. For me the 462 with a 28 would do anything I would touch and will scream with the 20.
Could that be just because they typically use shorter bars over there?
 
ElevatorGuy

ElevatorGuy

Yota’s and John Deere green!
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Sep 2, 2020
Messages
2,031
Location
Maryland
Could that be just because they typically use shorter bars over there?
I’m not sure. Could be a nice fill the gap saw between the 362 and 462 though. I don’t think we will see it in the states for a while. If we do get it before I pull the trigger and it’s priced closer to the 362 I’d think about it. If it’s $950+ I would just skip it.
 
Lionsfan

Lionsfan

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Aug 11, 2019
Messages
1,801
Location
Cheboygan, MI
Ace hears only sells echo. I’d hit my dealer where my jd tractor and my other stihl saw came from. Good old place, been around a long time.
The Ace we have has been here around 6 months. They don't do any repairs in house, and I bet they'd struggle to get you a chain let alone parts. No clue why they have a $1,200 saw on the shelf, but they do.
 
ElevatorGuy

ElevatorGuy

Yota’s and John Deere green!
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Sep 2, 2020
Messages
2,031
Location
Maryland
The Ace we have has been here around 6 months. They don't do any repairs in house, and I bet they'd struggle to get you a chain let alone parts. No clue why they have a $1,200 saw on the shelf, but they do.
Yeah, I love our local ace. It’s where I bought my echo stuff but yeah they’re not working on anything. That’s funny they have a 462, When I look online on the ace site I haven’t seen a pro saw at all. Just the homeowner and farm and ranch lines.
 
newforest

newforest

ArboristSite Operative
AS Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
260
Location
Michigan
I had to buy a $700 pro saw at an Ace hardware once upon a time in a really remote area (not the U.P.) where parts needs were a multi-day experience.

The saw service counter guy helped me complete all the details at the register; the saw as it had been sitting on the shelf didn’t have a plastic scabbard on it, so I asked him for one. There was a little stack of them for sale for two bucks but none of those matched the bar length I was buying. So he pulled one off another saw on the shelf and handed it to me. As he did, his manager came over and said “you can’t do that!” with a raised voice. Since my credit card had been run and I had the receipt in hand I looked her right in the eye, said nothing, and walked out the door.


Conversely my nearest local Stihl dealer is actually a tractor dealer; when my first M-Tronic saw had to be hooked up to the ‘pewter for something they had to go out and install the software on a laptop for the first time - after they had been carrying Stihl for 2 years already. They refuse to carry Stihl’s synthetic mix oil in the 5 gallon mix bottles at all; luckily my local Ace brought in Stihl and now carries about 4x the amount of Stihl stuff than my former “dealer.”
 
Mad Professor
Joined
Jul 2, 2007
Messages
18,246
Location
North East USA
I'd go with the 462 and a 25" bar. The 20" from the 261 will fit that too. The 462 with a 25" bar will allow you to chew some pretty big wood but the powerhead is not too big to use for stuff over rounds the 261 struggles with.

As far as big rounds. If they are too big for me to hand load I'll 1/2 or 1/4 them in the woods, or split them to firewood size in the woods. I take two mauls, a 8-lb sledge and 3-4 steel wedges with me, I don't noodle stuff.
 

U&A

The Millstead LLC
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
3,682
Location
Michigan
I'd go with the 462 and a 25" bar. The 20" from the 261 will fit that too. The 462 with a 25" bar will allow you to chew some pretty big wood but the powerhead is not too big to use for stuff over rounds the 261 struggles with.

As far as big rounds. If they are too big for me to hand load I'll 1/2 or 1/4 them in the woods, or split them to firewood size in the woods. I take two mauls, a 8-lb sledge and 3-4 steel wedges with me, I don't noodle stuff.

Why no noodling?


Sent while firmly grasping my redline lubed RAM [emoji231]
 
Mad Professor
Joined
Jul 2, 2007
Messages
18,246
Location
North East USA
Why no noodling?


Sent while firmly grasping my redline lubed RAM [emoji231]
Because I'm good at splitting big rounds and have tools to do so. Read each round for knots before you start.

If I have to, I break out the 20-lb sledge. Most big stuff, if the maul gets stuck I use it as a wedge and drive with the 8-lb sledge, and/or add a steel wedge. Not much that won't split with 2 mauls and 3-4 steel wedges.

I've never owned a splitter either. Been chopping/burning cordwood since the 1970s.

Door on my stove is 16 X 20". Seldom can't I split knotty crap down that far. Those are the all nighters.
 

Latest posts

Top