So what I gather is that's its a variable snake pit
Bel-Ray H1R Redux
- Thread starter RonL
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
What tests have you done that can be shared with us to substantiate your claims? Thanks.
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
I'd like to say that the AS forum is a learning forum. Hearsay or third party information is not as potent as first hand testing done as best as a contributor can be. We are not all the same or of the same capabilities. However we all seek to find the truths in this topic of oils.
Obviously this isn't mission critical as though our lives count on what perfect ratio or oil gets the job done best, but rather a quest to seek out what appears to each of us to be the Holy Grail. What is right for one may not be right for another, and that's OK.
Those with actual tests they have done themselves by all means POST the results! Nothing like firsthand information of a well intended member to inform all of their opinions and findings. And by taking the time and effort and money to post the results they are deserving of their findings regardless of the agreement of each of us.
Let's all in the Spirit of Learning give respect to those posting their personal results, don't like the results or how the test was run? Post your own. If you don't have your own to post at least be kind not to bash others. Don't have anything nice to say? Don't say!
Just what I think about this whole oil controversy. And until the end of time there will always be controversy over oil.
Bring on your TESTS!! Be Polite. And have fun here on Arborist Site!
Obviously this isn't mission critical as though our lives count on what perfect ratio or oil gets the job done best, but rather a quest to seek out what appears to each of us to be the Holy Grail. What is right for one may not be right for another, and that's OK.
Those with actual tests they have done themselves by all means POST the results! Nothing like firsthand information of a well intended member to inform all of their opinions and findings. And by taking the time and effort and money to post the results they are deserving of their findings regardless of the agreement of each of us.
Let's all in the Spirit of Learning give respect to those posting their personal results, don't like the results or how the test was run? Post your own. If you don't have your own to post at least be kind not to bash others. Don't have anything nice to say? Don't say!
Just what I think about this whole oil controversy. And until the end of time there will always be controversy over oil.
Bring on your TESTS!! Be Polite. And have fun here on Arborist Site!
I didn't have to test a thing in reference to the above, because someone did with alot better controls than I could muster.. the info is out there.
I might point out the last thread went to heck after the results of the test where questioned AS THEY SHOULD BE.
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
Again...what have YOU tested personally?
I know the answer !!!
Let me get this straight.. you would have us ignore sciresearch material and instead except some home grown BS test so full of holes it's ridiculous? You can do what you want, but personaly I want to have good information, not misinterpreted crap from a unscientific test.
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
That's not what I asked.
Yes, I have done plenty testing.
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
that's what we're looking for testing with a video. Thanks
Trx250r180
Saw polisher
Question ,if you took 16 oz of oil ,put it in a pan ,then burn it ,would it leave ash like on a spark plug ?
What have you tested? Do you have any photographic evidence of how great H1R is?
I'm guessing, but I think it would leave a nasty mess.
The ash buildup you have on your plug is likely the result of too much calcium and zinc in the formulation for what your doing. Steady and prolonged full throttle is really bad for ash formation too and that's why applications like general aviation oil and outboard motor oil are ashless.
porsche965
Addicted to ArboristSite
here we go again with Walker. I'm not playing your games. I never said h1r was. I have a lot of videos but no videos of testing oil. There's no way I can even begin to make a test with a critic like you in the crowd. I'm sure I'm not alone with these thoughts.
Trx250r180
Saw polisher
Thanks ,makes total sense .
I'm sure you can't too.. Most cant, at least not with the goals of the original test in question.
hacknstack
ArboristSite Lurker
Does anyone have any experience with the other Bel-Ray 2T premix oils? MC-1 and SL-2, specifically.
KenJax Tree
Terraphobic
I've used MC-1 in MX bikes and it worked well, but its really thick and Bel-Ray recommends 50:1
Back in the day MC1 and Golden spectro were very popular. Even at 50:1 or in the case of GS 60:1 they are pretty dirty by today's standards.
