White birch trees leaning over / almost fallen

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Scaramanga

New Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2023
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Location
New York
Hi there,
We’re in upstate NY.
We have a pond surrounded by white birches. This summer, more than half are now either leaning into the water, and some have completely uprooted. I’ve attached two photos. They all used to stand tall and straight, and looked lovely. The leaves are looking a bit off color too, even on the trees still standing straight.
We’ve had some storms but the weather hasn’t been extreme.
Any ideas what this could be? We’re seeing some white birches lean on other parts of our property too.
Best,
Adrian

https://share.icloud.com/photos/076hIsRjxWMQgEe766xUGrR8g
https://share.icloud.com/photos/0bbL4QAWOb8AJX5Y6wVfhO-Eg
 
Hi there,
We’re in upstate NY.
We have a pond surrounded by white birches. This summer, more than half are now either leaning into the water, and some have completely uprooted. I’ve attached two photos. They all used to stand tall and straight, and looked lovely. The leaves are looking a bit off color too, even on the trees still standing straight.
We’ve had some storms but the weather hasn’t been extreme.
Any ideas what this could be? We’re seeing some white birches lean on other parts of our property too.
Best,
Adrian

https://share.icloud.com/photos/076hIsRjxWMQgEe766xUGrR8g
https://share.icloud.com/photos/0bbL4QAWOb8AJX5Y6wVfhO-Eg

I can't view the photos. I think it's because it's on your icloud account and I use android.

Anyway, my guess is that the ground is soft/wet around your pond.
 
I can't view the photos. I think it's because it's on your icloud account and I use android.

Anyway, my guess is that the ground is soft/wet around your pond.
Hi Section 8,

The pond and trees have been there for many years, so if that hasn’t changed would ground conditions have changed sufficiently to cause this?

Here is an instagram link to the photos plus a video, hope it works:



Best,
Adrian
 
We'll need better pictures of the leaves to try and understand the discoloration.
As for the bending and uprooting, birches are pioneer species. They grow fast and are short lived. When you have a densely populated grove the competition encourages skinny trunks with top heavy crowns. Add in high water table and fertile soil and it's only a matter of time.
 
We'll need better pictures of the leaves to try and understand the discoloration.
As for the bending and uprooting, birches are pioneer species. They grow fast and are short lived. When you have a densely populated grove the competition encourages skinny trunks with top heavy crowns. Add in high water table and fertile soil and it's only a matter of time.
Thanks for the insights.
The timing seems odd, as the pond and trees have all been there for many years.
There are also a few cases of white birch bending (not uprooted) on other parts of the property, not adjacent to the pond. Those others groves have fared better overall though, with maybe 10-20% bending rather than more than half pond-side.
 
Have you seen any muskrat? They will dig burrows under the banks of the pond, and make a big mess of things.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top