Tree Felling House Smash

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
John Lyngdal

John Lyngdal

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Jan 5, 2017
Messages
1,340
Location
Eugene, OR
Looks like the sawyer/dimwit didn't make any notch and cut through the hinge.

The stump cuts were a mess. Not to mention that the tree had internal damage in the trunk region.
Just looking at the limb distribution, you could see that gravity was going to take towards the house.
The person with the saw was lazy and the house paid the price.
 
ChoppyChoppy

ChoppyChoppy

Tree Freak
Joined
Jun 17, 2013
Messages
10,617
Location
AK
I know, I do that much damage falling backwards when I'm drunk. (Pun intended)


Serious note:
If you got ten grand out of that, you are making cash. The joist & trusses held out fine. A couple 3 square of roof and some soffit, gutter & fascia and paint.
Just another day at the office...if you're a hack, cowboy.

Hard to tell. The one builder talked about it being unsafe to live, so I'd have to think it's more than just damage to the porch area.
 
Westboastfaller

Westboastfaller

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
May 16, 2014
Messages
4,438
Location
Here
By the stump I think its the case of a sloping backcut which all pros know make it fall against its natural lean.
Three cuts in the back cut, what a butcher job!
In regards to a sloping back cut. (For the record, I have never done one) Well it doesn't make it fall against the natural lean, per sa. It wouldn't make a difference if it was 180° from the fall of a natural forward direction.
In this case the tree ended up landing about 120° to the low/back side of the intended direction of fall
In cases similar to the same gravity pull with a traditional back cut then the tree may pressure *down* on a larger curvature without breaking the holding wood. In terms of an exaggerated slopping cut then it will preasure on the top/back of the lower/down side of the back first,, and which is becomes a 'sharper' point. Now it's leveraging off the one side of the point and is free to twist opposed to sit down .
Add wind to the scenario and it could be a big deal. I am pretty good at the physics of this trade but if someone can offer something different then I'm all ears.
--------
On a back lean, all of the above can happen with a SBC
The hack, really could be creating a leverage point. A bar pinch may contribute or combination with wind or inadequate holding wood.

A cut off tree with a reg back cut will start to fall slow and be consistent.
A back leaner will a SBC gone wrong, will quickly shoot off the stump and drop to the low side.
-----
He obviously wanted to fall it that way for clean up purposes but there is levels to this game (not that this would be hard) and that boy is at ground zero. He would have been fine the other way.
This cowboy badly cut off half the tension side holding wood on a tree that had high potential to hit the house on that direction (if done wrong..which it was)
Once he fell the snipe off, he was on track to utilized the greater advantage .
That he did but fooked it up.
Rookieville!!!
 
Westboastfaller

Westboastfaller

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
May 16, 2014
Messages
4,438
Location
Here
Hard to tell. The one builder talked about it being unsafe to live, so I'd have to think it's more than just damage to the porch area.
That guy was full of §hit.
Nothing wrong with the structure. The joists looked solid. You can tell the trusses were in tact. I would do that in a week after work.
 
softdown

softdown

There is only Ingsoc.
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Oct 6, 2020
Messages
739
Location
Southern Colorado mountains
That guy was full of §hit.
Nothing wrong with the structure. The joists looked solid. You can tell the trusses were in tact. I would do that in a week after work.
Yea - then you get code involved and need an architect, engineers, remodel permit, etc. etc. That is why houses cost too much. So few want to deal with the ********. This makes rent cost too much as well. Then you have angry youth wanting to fight the system - by making it bigger.
 
Westboastfaller

Westboastfaller

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
May 16, 2014
Messages
4,438
Location
Here
Yea - then you get code involved and need an architect, engineers, remodel permit, etc. etc. That is why houses cost too much. So few want to deal with the ********. This makes rent cost too much as well. Then you have angry youth wanting to fight the system - by making it bigger.
I'm not a young angry man, I am just angry! ..lol
Jokes aside, I agree with what you say,100%
 
TimberMcPherson

TimberMcPherson

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
Mar 13, 2003
Messages
5,884
Location
New Zealand
Three cuts in the back cut, what a butcher job!
In regards to a sloping back cut. (For the record, I have never done one) Well it doesn't make it fall against the natural lean, per sa. It wouldn't make a difference if it was 180° from the fall of a natural forward direction.
In this case the tree ended up landing about 120° to the low/back side of the intended direction of fall
In cases similar to the same gravity pull with a traditional back cut then the tree may pressure *down* on a larger curvature without breaking the holding wood. In terms of an exaggerated slopping cut then it will preasure on the top/back of the lower/down side of the back first,, and which is becomes a 'sharper' point. Now it's leveraging off the one side of the point and is free to twist opposed to sit down .
Add wind to the scenario and it could be a big deal. I am pretty good at the physics of this trade but if someone can offer something different then I'm all ears.
--------
On a back lean, all of the above can happen with a SBC
The hack, really could be creating a leverage point. A bar pinch may contribute or combination with wind or inadequate holding wood.

A cut off tree with a reg back cut will start to fall slow and be consistent.
A back leaner will a SBC gone wrong, will quickly shoot off the stump and drop to the low side.
-----
He obviously wanted to fall it that way for clean up purposes but there is levels to this game (not that this would be hard) and that boy is at ground zero. He would have been fine the other way.
This cowboy badly cut off half the tension side holding wood on a tree that had high potential to hit the house on that direction (if done wrong..which it was)
Once he fell the snipe off, he was on track to utilized the greater advantage .
That he did but fooked it up.
Rookieville!!!
I know, I said it all in jest
 
Westboastfaller

Westboastfaller

Addicted to ArboristSite
. AS Supporting Member.
Joined
May 16, 2014
Messages
4,438
Location
Here
Anyone care to post a working link to the video?


Try Home ruined by Tree Lopper/ Current Affair
You should be able to see it on FB if this doesn't work.

I am posting out of the UK these days and can't always see vids from the states. Usually will read. "This video is not available in your country "
 

Latest posts

Top