Back when I started flipping saws, $40 was a lot to pay for a saw with a toasted topend. I’ve bought truckloads of 044, 046, 064, 066 from Stihl dealers for $10-$20 each because the aftermarket was still somewhat new and OEM topends made it cost prohibitive to repair them. Since the Chicom market took off, there are plenty of guys willing to throw a $30 Chicom topend on a saw and peddle it on Craigslist, Feepay, FB market place, or wherever. So, when I was paying $20 for a toasted 066 and putting $350 worth of OEM parts in them to make them right, I could make $100-$200 for my labor (all condition dependent of course). Since I refuse to put a Chicom topend on a saw, it’s no longer worth it to me to buy toasted saws and repair them for a profit. I’m not competing with guys that will pay $300 for a toasted 066. I think on feepay, his saw would fetch $250-$300. You asked what a fair price is for it? A fair price is honestly $50-$75 tops to someone that is going to fix it right. Of course he isn’t going to sell it for that, and I don’t blame him in the situation we are in. That’s another “blessing” we have from Chicom junk, flood the market with junk, starting with a saw they over paid for that costs the end user the same amount of money as a saw that was bought at the right price, and repaired correctly with OEM parts.