I mostly cut fir and alder(both split pretty easy). I think I am going to cut an 1 1/4 out of the wedge down 5 inches. Make a 2 stage splitting wedge, if that makes sence. It should help with the force by making the lower section start to split then the upper section comes into play. The new plate is 8 inches long, that is as long as I can make it without a full rebuild of the entire splitter.
I hear you with as much as you can do for a plate. Sometimes you just have to go with what you can. By the pic it looks like your current one has angled allready?
I redid the slide on my Dads splitter years ago and converted it to a box slide on the double H beam as his was moving and bending. He ran it too long with too many flexes and ended up braking the cylinder end off at the last thread. He wanted to keep going and called me to see if I could reweld it on so he could keep going till a new cylinder arrived. Penciled both sides and kept welding till it was to OD size again. Used it to finish the job till New Cylinder came in. Rebuilt the slide and he said leave the old cylinder on till it breaks. It never did!
You're probably fine with what you say you are splitting. I'm used to hardwoods, knots and twistys so we have to overbuild for it.