mondays live oak removal

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
John464

John464

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Jan 18, 2006
Messages
1,162
Location
NJ
massive. I too would like to know why it's being removed.

I assume the reason why he is only posting a few pics is so that no one identifies the tree for two reasons:

-Tree huggers trying to stop him from removal

-Competitors trying to get a last minute bid on the job to undercut
 
OLD CHIPMONK

OLD CHIPMONK

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
518
Location
S.E. Georgia 31404
All trees are contained, inventoried & computer cataloged by the City of Savannah Park & Tree Services. Trees located on commercial, institutional or multi-family developments are also protected from removal. Some of our local & out of town tree services are cutting said, protected trees ie: Live Oaks... If it is found to be a Hazzard Tree ( determined by our City Forrester ) a permit is issued. New developments must preserve " GREEN SPACE '" & buffer zones of not less than 25 ft. Variences are not allowable. Strict guidelines & rigorous enforcement of Tree Ordinanaces are now in effect. Fines of $ 5000.00 for illegall pruning & higher for illegall removals. We refuse to remove a healthy Live Oak at any time. We are not adverse to reporting the offending party or service. We simply love our trees as a great asset to Historic Savannah, Ga. . Remember a healthy tree generates of lot of income, for all of us, over it's lifetime.
 
kkottemann

kkottemann

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jun 22, 2006
Messages
387
Location
New Orleans,La/Poplarville, MS
If the tree is where I think it is, which I really don't have an Idea, It is probabbly dead and pose a serious hazzard to people. If that is the case it must come down. Remember we had 20 feet of water in some areas around here for 2 weeks. Nasty, brackish, toxic water. this fact has really put the trees under enormous stresses over the long haul. By the time it is all done around here everything will be demolished and rebuilt...including trees.
 
COLD_IRON

COLD_IRON

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Jul 25, 2007
Messages
1,085
Location
Oak Harbor WA
All trees are contained, inventoried & computer cataloged by the City of Savannah Park & Tree Services. Trees located on commercial, institutional or multi-family developments are also protected from removal. Some of our local & out of town tree services are cutting said, protected trees ie: Live Oaks... If it is found to be a Hazzard Tree ( determined by our City Forrester ) a permit is issued. New developments must preserve " GREEN SPACE '" & buffer zones of not less than 25 ft. Variences are not allowable. Strict guidelines & rigorous enforcement of Tree Ordinanaces are now in effect. Fines of $ 5000.00 for illegall pruning & higher for illegall removals. We refuse to remove a healthy Live Oak at any time. We are not adverse to reporting the offending party or service. We simply love our trees as a great asset to Historic Savannah, Ga. . Remember a healthy tree generates of lot of income, for all of us, over it's lifetime.

Sounds about right. Remove an Oak around here and you are in BIG trouble.

After all, the name of the city I live in - Oak Harbor :)
 
BlueRidgeMark

BlueRidgeMark

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Aug 26, 2005
Messages
7,836
Location
Virginia
See the 2nd photo, and note the missing bark....That's a good clue as to the condition and reason for removal. That surely is an awesome trunk, looking forward to more from ya.


Doesn't look to good in picture 1, either. Yeah, it's a crying shame, but if it's dead, it's dead.


I have to say, the quality of the model went waaaaay down in the 2nd photo! :dizzy:
 
Last edited:
rbtree

rbtree

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
May 5, 2001
Messages
5,209
Location
Seattle
If the location would allow, that would be a great tree to leave a habitat snag...maybe with the side leads only 8-12 feet long to reduce failure risk. Then, it's once grand stature could be remembered for a few more years, while another tree (or three) grows nearby.
 
Top