Leary of NOS rubber parts, would really depend on age + condition. Seals installed in a saw and soaked in oil, they'll last nearly forever. In a dry paper envelope, on a dusty shelf, or especially in the sun, toast in fairly short order.
If the seals are still soft and pliable, don't hold an impression when pushed on with a fingernail, return to position when flexed, I'd probably be good with them.
New OEM seal > new major manufacturer dimensionally identical non-OEM seal > NOS seal.