Type of oak found in Long Island NY

[adedeluca]

Can anybody positively identify the proper species in our property

Thank you very much

 

[Lightning Performance]

Can anybody positively identify the proper species in our property

Thank you very much

You posted two different types.
Both are in the red oak group. One could be a hybrid mixed with chestnut oak or something else. Not a pure white oak type. The other appears to be scarlet or in the red group.

Don't have my book here to positively ID them. More information is helpful.
Bark, canopy pics with out leaves present and the base area.

 

[adedeluca]

You posted two different types.
Both are in the red oak group. One could be a hybrid mixed with chestnut oak or something else. Not a pure white oak type. The other appears to be scarlet or in the red group.

Don't have my book here to positively ID them. More information is helpful.
Bark, canopy pics with out leaves present and the base area.

We thought one was Northen Red Oak and the other a white oak after search online for hours and hours

 

[Lightning Performance]

We thought one was Northen Red Oak and the other a white oak after search online for hours and hours

The white oak leaf doesn't look like a regular one imo. It should appear as a ghost shape. This has longer lobes.

Red oak group for sure on the other one.

 

[buzz sawyer]

L to R - White family and Red family. Leaf size can be affected by growing conditions. Can you post pics of the bark in different places on the trunks?

 

[esean]

We thought one was Northen Red Oak and the other a white oak after search online for hours and hours

I agree. The left one is more deeply lobed than some white oaks, but I see many like that. There's lots of tree-to-tree variation. The right one could actually be scarlet oak (assuming you have them on LI) instead of northern red due to the deep sinuses, but its definitely one of the reds.