Which saw and is it worth it

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
STLfirewood

STLfirewood

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
2,186
Location
St. louis MO
I am going to buy new saw. I have narrowed it down to either a 346xp or a 357xp. I am leaning towards the 346xp because of the weight of it. The saw will run a 16inch bar. It will be use for limbing and bucking small wood (up to 16inches) and clearing small cedars. I have bigger saws for bigger wood. My next question, is it worth it to have it power tuned. I won't be doing this myself I will be sending it to Walkers Saw Shop. I want something that will not be touchy and have to be adjusted all the time. I am rather hard on a saw when it comes to upkeep. I am slow about changing filter and things like that. Is it worth it to be tuned for the $200. here are the other saws I have maybe that will help you with advice.

029 stihl ran great for 10 years cut fast. cut over 700 ranks fo wood. hated the 4 position switch that wanted to break all the time. wouldn't stay running sold on ebay

026 pro. Had this saw 4 years bought it used. It never seemed to have the power that it should. Always started and ran great never a problem just cut slow. loved the size and weight. oiler quit oiling sold on ebay

Echo 670 Had this saw for 5 years and loved it. I put 3 gallons of fuel through it the first day i had it. Great power easy to clean air filter simple on off switch. It needed bigger saw spikes and a little more anti vibrartion. I adjusted the carb toi lean and burned a piston (this is why I don't touch them)

Husky 359. had 2 years runs great good power to weight really like this saw.

Stihl 046 mag This is my favorite saw. It has a 36inch bar and loves to run. I only use this for the big stuff and have to keep myself from throwing a 20inch bar on it and using it everyday. I want it to stay around a long time to cut the big stuff. I don't want to spend the money to buy another one.

Echo 520 It starts and runs great. Cuts slow I think it needs to be adjusted but this is the trash saw. It stays in the back of the truck through everykind of weather incase there is a need on the farm.

Thanks for any input.

Scott
 
romeo

romeo

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Mar 17, 2006
Messages
2,436
Location
Sunspot NM
Go for the 346, since you already have a 359. The 357 is the same size and weight as the 359, it is just a little bit quicker.

Actually, just get them both.:monkey:
 
GASoline71

GASoline71

Mr. Nice Guy
Joined
Jul 12, 2005
Messages
9,663
Location
The Great Pacific Northwest
I am rather hard on a saw when it comes to upkeep. I am slow about changing filter and things like that. Is it worth it to be tuned for the $200. here are the other saws I have maybe that will help you with advice.

If you are lazy on upkeep... don't spend the money on having anything done to the saw... hell, might as well just run the stuff you have.

Saw upkeep is a major part of ownin' a saw. If your gonna treat a port tuned saw like the average Joe with dirty filters... you will never get the full potential of the saw.

Skip it...:popcorn:

Gary
 
SawTroll

SawTroll

Information Collector
Joined
Jan 13, 2005
Messages
64,856
Location
Troms, North Norway
026 pro. Had this saw 4 years bought it used. It never seemed to have the power that it should. Always started and ran great never a problem just cut slow. loved the size and weight. oiler quit oiling sold on ebay

Then, the 346 xp is your saw - same weight, faster cutting in smaller wood, much better air filter system and anti-vibe (if you care).
The new 50cc version will surely be even better........

Husky 359. had 2 years runs great good power to weight really like this saw.

The power to weight ratio is not great at all for that saw, but I guess it could feel like it is, when you compare it to the MS290 and CS670 (they are worse) - enter the 357xp, or preferably the MS361.......;)
 
Last edited:
Hired Gun

Hired Gun

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
419
Location
New Salem, Ma
Very solid advice all around on this one. You have the 359 no need for the 357. You don't like to work on stuff so don't get crazy with mods, you won't see any benefit w/o maintenance. The 346 is a great small saw. I love mine dearly. :love1:
 
Last edited:
STLfirewood

STLfirewood

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
2,186
Location
St. louis MO
Thanks for the advice. I just ordered a saw. I went with the 346xp. It should be here in a couple days. I bought the saw with a 16inch bar. It came with a total of 3 chains. Price was $417.90 shipped to my door. I didn't think this was to bad. Again thanks for the help. No I just have to decide weather or not to mod the saw. Can anyone reccomend someone. Roght now I'm thinking about just having walker do it. Anyone else I should consider. This will be my first modded saw.

Thanks Scott
 
STLfirewood

STLfirewood

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
2,186
Location
St. louis MO
It will be cutting a lot more oak then cedar. I cut all different types of wod doing tree trimming and cutting firewood. If i have it tuned I will make the effort to do the filters and such. Before it would kill me to change the filters and spend $25 to service a $300 saw when it cut good. I just banged them out. I kind of always thought oh well if it goes out I'll just buy another. I think the 029 only had one filter change in 10 years. It cut over 700 ranks of wood. Thanks for the input.

Scott
 
Top