A Good $1500 Wood Splitter?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Goon 88

ArboristSite Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2009
Messages
59
Reaction score
12
Location
Hopkinton, MA
My brother and I are looking at a few new splitters. We have whittled it down to the Troy Built 22 Ton hydrolic splitter and the Wood Wolf. Anyone know of anything why we should or shouldn't be looking at either? I really like the Supersplit, but at $2600 + 6.25% tax, it's a little too much. Any imput would be appreciated.

Thanks,

BT
 
Do yourself a big favor, and forget the troybuilt or any similar made splitter.
Watch craigslist, and scoop up a timberwolf TW-1 or TW-2.
You want one of them, or a similar made machine with a 4 way splitting wedge. The kind (like troybuilt) with the wedge on the ram SUCK.
They are purely homeowner amature machines. Great for doing 6 cord a year.
Trust me on this.
 
I Have a Duerr Brand with the wedge on the ram and love it, it does Vertical & Horizontal, it's only 25ton but in 5+ years I have only come across 2 or 3 pieces of Crotch or twist that it didn't breeze right through, and I only do 6-8 cords a year. I got it for free and just needed to replace the 7hp motor, so I have $219.00 in it :cheers:
 
I'd go with the $1099 ($999 this week) Huskee splitter at TSC before even sniffing the 22-ton Troy-Bilt.

Troy-bilt = lower beam, poorly designed log cradle (logs will catch and bend it), weak log dislodger, difficult service & turn around time.

I got my Huskee 35-ton last summer and have been very pleased. With a 10% off coupon, it's near your price limit.
 
Last edited:
That Huskee 22 ton is almost exactly like my splitter. I'm happy with it, don't see the need for more power since it's very rare it won't split what I feed it.
 
Do yourself a big favor, and forget the troybuilt or any similar made splitter.
Watch craigslist, and scoop up a timberwolf TW-1 or TW-2.
You want one of them, or a similar made machine with a 4 way splitting wedge. The kind (like troybuilt) with the wedge on the ram SUCK.
They are purely homeowner amature machines. Great for doing 6 cord a year.
Trust me on this.


What WTF??
I got the TB, and the only thing I found to be a pain was the weak log cradle.And I dont crank out only six cords of wood a year.More in the neighborhood of 40 cords a year.Been using that splitter for 4 years now, and not a thing to complain about.I have the 27 ton model, and after dropping a 4way wedge on the thing I can crank out some wood with that thing.

I modded mine with a full table instead of the log cradle and production is pretty good.Honda engine cranks on third pull after sitting there all winter with fresh fuel,engine is quiet enough to endure for long periods of time,and absolutely nothing else to complain about.

Log splitters are simple machines really.Not a lot of moving parts,and as long as they meet certain criteria most of them are decent machines.
Here is what I would look for if looking for a new machine.

Is it comfortable?Do you have to bend over to use it?are the controls easy to reach,tires and fenders out of the way?

Are parts easy to obtain or interchangeable with other models?In other words,if your valve goes tits up, can you just swap out with a standard log splitting valve or do you have to buy a "factory" branded part?

Warranty!What do they do for you if the valve leaks,make you wait a year for a new one to show up on a slow boat from China?How long is the warranty, and do they make a disclaimer between commercial and homeowner?

Major parts like wedge,ram,beam, and toe plate.Are they built stout and are the welds done correctly?There have been a number of complaints about crappy welds on Speeco lately.

Do the Tonnage ratings match up to the components.In other words, do they claim its a 27 ton and it comes with a 5hp engine and a 3 inch cylinder?

Cycly times.If they advertise it a 12 second cycle time,does it really do that?Name of the game for any splitter is strength and speed.27 tons and 14 seconds is good for most folks,especially if you can outfit it with a 4way wedge.

And last but not least,what about its rep?Do a search on the boards here, and I am fairly sure that no matter what type of machine you are looking at,someone around here has one, operated one,or knows someone who has one.

For the dollars involved, I have found that the Troy Built machine is plenty good.with a 4way head and a good table bolted on it will hold its own against anything in the same price range.Buying a used splitter is a crap shoot.You might find a real gem for a decent price,but then again you might find one that has never had its oil changed, hydralic filter is the same factory one,and in the case of a close friend that looked at one off of craigslist, spent a significant amount of its time running with the governor wired wide open because as the guy put it, "Shoot,it will really spit out the wood with that thingy wired down."
 
What WTF??
I got the TB, and the only thing I found to be a pain was the weak log cradle.And I dont crank out only six cords of wood a year.More in the neighborhood of 40 cords a year.Been using that splitter for 4 years now, and not a thing to complain about.I have the 27 ton model, and after dropping a 4way wedge on the thing I can crank out some wood with that thing.

I modded mine with a full table instead of the log cradle and production is pretty good.Honda engine cranks on third pull after sitting there all winter with fresh fuel,engine is quiet enough to endure for long periods of time,and absolutely nothing else to complain about.

+1 Thanks for saving me the writing. I have and done exactly the same thing with my 27 ton TB. Wood table, 4 way wedge. Also, if your splitter doesn't go to a vertical position (wedge on ram) you will need a log lift to get them on........unless you only split "little" logs......
 
A 27-Ton Troy built splitter - Hydraulic Reservoir Size: 3 Gallons :jawdrop: It should be like 8 gallons. 19 second cycle time.... Not nearly enough hydraulic capacity. Lots of complaints about the spider gears breaking between the pump and motor.

IMO the Swishers, MTD's, Troybuilts dont come close to a lot of splitters on the market.
 
A 27-Ton Troy built splitter - Hydraulic Reservoir Size: 3 Gallons :jawdrop: It should be like 8 gallons. 19 second cycle time.... Not nearly enough hydraulic capacity. Lots of complaints about the spider gears breaking between the pump and motor.

IMO the Swishers, MTD's, Troybuilts dont come close to a lot of splitters on the market.


That seems kinda funny.Lots of complaints?I tried a google search under "troy bilt log splitter complaints" and finally gave up after the first six pages of not one complaint.

Oh,and one other thing.Cycle time is 14 seconds, not 19.Quite exagerating just to prove your point.
 
That seems kinda funny.Lots of complaints?I tried a google search under "troy bilt log splitter complaints" and finally gave up after the first six pages of not one complaint.

Oh,and one other thing.Cycle time is 14 seconds, not 19.Quite exagerating just to prove your point.

lol just to prove my point? Exaggerate? Jeez I know you love your splitter and I am glad, you should. Nothing personal toward you or any other owner. I found several sites with the specs including this one. Lowes http://www.lowes.com/pd_116418-270-...05417&Ntt=log splitter&Ntk=i_products

Clearly says 19 second cycle time. Does it not? They even have reviews good and bad. We can express our opinions right?
 
+1 Thanks for saving me the writing. I have and done exactly the same thing with my 27 ton TB. Wood table, 4 way wedge. Also, if your splitter doesn't go to a vertical position (wedge on ram) you will need a log lift to get them on........unless you only split "little" logs......

If the OP wants one, great, but if he wants to do wood for delivery on a regular basis, then the Timberwolf is 20x the machine. Horizontal/vertical machines are for women.

20080812_1519-PattiSplittingWood.jpg
 
I'd go with the $1099 ($999 this week) Huskee splitter at TSC before even sniffing the 22-ton Troy-Bilt.

:agree2:


I can remember when Troy-Bilt meant good quality. Not any more.


As to what you should get, that depends on your needs. If you are trying to split wood for money, you need to raise your budget considerably.

If it's for home use, the Huskee/Speeco will more than meet your needs, in that price range. Customer service can't be beat. There ARE better splitters out there, I've heard, but at that price point, there is NOTHING that comes close to the value for the money. To get something completely American made will take you into the $2500 range. (Iron & Oak or the equivalent.)

The Speeco's built in log cradle is VERY nice. :cheers:
 
If the OP wants one, great, but if he wants to do wood for delivery on a regular basis, then the Timberwolf is 20x the machine. Horizontal/vertical machines are for women.

Hmm.vertical machines are for women eh?
Tell you what.You drag home some of the rounds that I do.You know, those 68 inchers of solid white oak.you know, the rounds that are so heavy they flop over on ya before you get a chance to noodle em up.Drag em up in your trailer and haul em home.Then figure out how you are going to get them up on your horizontal machine since you wont be able to noodlem up when they are flat laying on their side.
There is a time and a place for everything,and there are times when a vertical machine is just plain nice rather than trying to figure out how you are going to get them up on a horizontal machine.

So far you have ignored everything that was said by the OP.he doesnt plan on laying out the bucks for a TW,and if the Troy Bilt fits his needs, its not a bad machine for the money.
And,like I said, a Troy Bilt is not a bad machine period. I have consistantly put 40 cords a year through that machine for the last four years without a wimper,and that in itself should be testament for any machine.There are a number of members on here who will also attest to the machine.

I dare you to come on over to my place and take a look at my woodpile at the end of October and call me a woman to my face.I dare say you will spend a good bit of time in the ER for your efforts.
 
Hmm.vertical machines are for women eh?
Tell you what.You drag home some of the rounds that I do.You know, those 68 inchers of solid white oak.you know, the rounds that are so heavy they flop over on ya before you get a chance to noodle em up.Drag em up in your trailer and haul em home.Then figure out how you are going to get them up on your horizontal machine since you wont be able to noodlem up when they are flat laying on their side.


There is a time and a place for everything,and there are times when a vertical machine is just plain nice rather than trying to figure out how you are going to get them up on a horizontal machine.

:agree2:


Mine rounds go 24" to 40", and I don't care if you have a log lift or not, that's vertical split territory.


Don't sweat it, avalancher. Some people judge their manhood by how much money they spend on equipment. :monkey:
 
I prefer HV splitters as I am 6'7", so the height of the beam is much higher on HV's so its a better working height. Timber wolf makes a great splitter. Several for that matter, but they do cost a pretty penny. American is another good one. Here is another HV http://www.woodsplittersdirect.com/product_info.php?cPath=2_21&products_id=26 but I think I would do the 5.5 Honda GX160 or even the GX 240.

Yeah MTD/TB same Husky/Speeco
 
For the record, I don't have a big problem with Troy-Bilt/MTD clone splitters. They have their place and can meet the splitting needs of a lot of people. As others have stated here, log splitters are not rocket science; the basic components are the same and sometimes exactly the same. For a price that's lower than most, you can get decent tonnage with the Troy-Bilt (27 or 33 tons). My point was the SpeeCo/Huskee splitter is a good value choice for me because it has the characteristics and features I care about at a low price. Others may not place such a high value on, say, the height of the splitter beam or the durability of a log dislodger.

I'll also state that a lot of the deficiencies in a splitter are no big deal for the tinkerer who can use a drill or can weld.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top