Dolmar...
- Thread starter 5speed
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
cedarshark
Addicted to ArboristSite
300 truckloads is a lot of wood. I would buy a used 60-70 cc saw rather than a new 40 cc.
SawTroll
Information Collector
Yes, definately! :msp_thumbup:
exSW
ArboristSite Guru
I have a 420 I'm on my third gallon of gas since I bought it three weeks ago so it's getting used.If you are cutting that much big wood get a bigger saw with a pro bar or at least look into fitting a Pro Bar to the 421 at which point you will be into the 60ccish price range anyway.
fastLeo151
Addicted to ArboristSite
I have a great relationship with that dealer, if I'm not mistaken I think cost on that was around 260.00
Great Smokies
ArboristSite Operative
Never heard of 'breather' issues, and primers making saws weak? :msp_confused:
The 420's nylon filter has been changed for a different flock on the new 421, so if it was an issue, which I don't think it was, then it isn't. The 421 is built like a tank and cuts well above what a 42cc saw should be expected to. Use it for what it is intended and you will have a fine saw.
The 420's nylon filter has been changed for a different flock on the new 421, so if it was an issue, which I don't think it was, then it isn't. The 421 is built like a tank and cuts well above what a 42cc saw should be expected to. Use it for what it is intended and you will have a fine saw.
tallguys
Addicted to ArboristSite
The 421 is a great saw for what it is, though if it's larger wood the 510 would provide you with more power.
SawTroll
Information Collector
exSW
ArboristSite Guru
Handled an Efco 165(64cc) this morning couple of hundred more than a 421 but man that thing was light for the size of it.Aluminum block.
mitch95100
Saw Nut
It was an answer to the first question in post #1.
I was just asking what you heard the problems were?
Sent from me to you using my fingers
mitch95100
Saw Nut
SawTroll
Information Collector
Dust getting past the filter, and filters getting dirty faster than on some other saws.
I have never said it is a real issue though, just something to be aware of.
MGlazier28
ArboristSite Member
I have the 420, and it is a great saw. . .mine was bought as basically a limbing saw, and has been used in sugar maple up to around 18" or so. After a MM and re-tune, it is waaaaaay stronger than any other 40cc saw I've ever run. In fact, it will give many 50cc saws a run for the money. As for the air filtration- my stihls at work have more of a problem with fine dust getting through the filter than my 420 (or my 7900, for that matter). You should easily be able to cut all day with no problems- mine has shown only a little dust on the filter after 5-6 hours of cutting.
cedarshark
Addicted to ArboristSite
300 truckloads @ approx 1/4 cord a truckload = 75 cords. I think he needs a pro quality saw w/ enough cajones to pull a 20" bar without undue stress to man or machine. I vote for a good used 036/360 and if he really wants to have a little fun...an 044/440. That way, when he is done cutting wood for 30 straight days(at 2.5 cords per day)....he will have something left over worth having. I cut a cord and 1/2 this aft with an 034 super...it was a workout...but I am 61. Certified "old fart". I will be :msp_sleep: soon.
MGlazier28
ArboristSite Member
Yes, even after all my praise of the little dolmar, I would personally want a 60cc saw with a 20" bar for that much/size cutting. . .036/360/361 used if ya like stihl, 357/359 used husky, 2156/2159 jonsered, etc.
MGlazier28
ArboristSite Member
In that case, the 421 should serve you well and last a long time. They sure are a LOT of saw for the money!
tallguys
Addicted to ArboristSite
Personally if i had the clams id go ps5105.
But i dont.
Have my super xl ao for the big stuff.
~5-Speed~
The 5105 is my current choice... if you have the cash get one. Otherwise the 510 is really not a bad choice, it just doesn't get the credit it deserves on this site.
Power-wise its pretty much right between a 5105 and 421.
SawTroll
Information Collector
By all means avoid the chi-com option!
One thing that hasn't really been discussed here is if the weight of the saw is an issue to your dad - or if it is a pure money issue?
Last edited:
Similar threads
