currently the size ranges of the trees would be from 2" all the way to 8" or 9". I am thinking that I might purchase the ps5100 with a 16 inch bar. A little heavier than the 346 but also seems to have more power. It seems that it gets good reviews.
husqvarna 346xp VS. STIHL MS260PRO
- Thread starter epc
- Start date
Help Support Arborist Forum:
Erick
Addicted to ArboristSite
+1 for Stihl
(Keep in mind that I have not run a 346xp or a 5100)
I run a muff mod'd MS260 with a 16" bar and Stihl 26RS chain (.325 x .63) with an 8-pin sprocket if there’s a better limb (1" to 12") machine out there I would love to try it out. This set up works well for light felling and bucking too but if I were doing larger than 14" hardwood on a regular basis I would go back to the 7-pin sprocket.
(Keep in mind that I have not run a 346xp or a 5100)
I run a muff mod'd MS260 with a 16" bar and Stihl 26RS chain (.325 x .63) with an 8-pin sprocket if there’s a better limb (1" to 12") machine out there I would love to try it out. This set up works well for light felling and bucking too but if I were doing larger than 14" hardwood on a regular basis I would go back to the 7-pin sprocket.
Just curious what that down time could be ? IMO, the 346 has:
- Much better anti vibe.
- Air filtration . As much better as it could possibly get. Sthil seems to have this self-get-dirty-automatic-mechanism that basically sucks the dirt into the filer. Didn't pay much attention to it before when I only ran my 026. But now when I compare to the 353 ...
- Much faster acceleration.
- Better ergonomics.
In all, a saw with better performance and less maintenance.
Also, not to forget. My 353 has much lower fuel consumption than my 026.
Maybe that's true for 346/260 as well?
/Peter
Just curious what that down time could be ? IMO, the 346 has:
- Much better anti vibe.
- Air filtration . As much better as it could possibly get. Sthil seems to have this self-get-dirty-automatic-mechanism that basically sucks the dirt into the filer. Didn't pay much attention to it before when I only ran my 026. But now when I compare to the 353 ...
- Much faster acceleration.
- Better ergonomics.
In all, a saw with better performance and less maintenance.
Also, not to forget. My 353 has much lower fuel consumption than my 026.
Maybe that's true for 346/260 as well?
/Peter
The ms260/026 is a boat anchor of a aw and the worst pro saw stihl makes. The 346 bests it in every way.
And Yes I have owned a 260 and a 346 at the same time. I dont think anyone who has owned both will say the 260 is the better saw. The armchair experts are a different story though.
And Yes I have owned a 260 and a 346 at the same time. I dont think anyone who has owned both will say the 260 is the better saw. The armchair experts are a different story though.
tek9tim
ArboristSite Guru
The armchair experts are a different story though.
So I'm going to pipe up, even though I've only run the 260. (and not much at that) I'm not impressed with the 260, but I also run bigger saws, and am used to using an 044 with a 32" bar for everything. (you don't carry 2 saws on a fire) SO, the 260 is weak to me. However, I don't have any comparison to anything else in the class. Earlier in the week, I decided to buy a 50cc saw, so I went through this decision as well. I ended up going with the 5100. The 260 wasn't my cup of tea, and I've had some bad luck with Huskies. (although I can count on one hand the huskies I've run) Nothing too bad, it just kinda seemed like the Stihl voodoo gods were making little things go wrong to scare me away. I've heard great things about the 5100, so I figured I'd give it a go. Haven't gotten it yet, so no review yet. Get the saw that works for you. Better yet, get the saw that the dealer works for you. Saw to saw, I'd avoid the 260, the 346 and 5100 are more modern designs. That means something from a Stihl guy.
IF YOU HAVE A GOOD DOLMAR DEALER the 5100 is also a option. I would take it over a 260 as well.
GASoline71
Mr. Nice Guy
When someone says A vs. B, how come some of y'all always say C! or D!
Is it failure to understand the question?
You got me dude... no matter what make of saw somebody wants a comparison with... 3 differnt saw makes will be offered up.
I don't get it either...
Gary
346xp
SinglerM
ArboristSite Operative
346
Between the Husky 346 and the Stihl S260. I'd get the 346.
You didn't ask about it in your original post, but it got mentioned along the way...the Dolmar 5100s is a good saw, I have one , and like it.
But between the three.
1st- Husky 346. Light and strong.
2nd-Dolmar 5100s. It does "seem" a little better built, but it's negligible. Especially for a 50cc or so sized saw.
3rd-Stihl MS260 Pro.
Husky 346, in my opinion.
I know this is an older thread, but....I was bored.
Take care,
Mitch
Between the Husky 346 and the Stihl S260. I'd get the 346.
You didn't ask about it in your original post, but it got mentioned along the way...the Dolmar 5100s is a good saw, I have one , and like it.
But between the three.
1st- Husky 346. Light and strong.
2nd-Dolmar 5100s. It does "seem" a little better built, but it's negligible. Especially for a 50cc or so sized saw.
3rd-Stihl MS260 Pro.
Husky 346, in my opinion.
I know this is an older thread, but....I was bored.
Take care,
Mitch
Something about the 260 feels really solid. I am certain that it will last a very long time. Very reliable, handles really well too.
That being said, the 346 is the all around better performer.
Its not even debatable.
Less vibes, faster cutter, more powerful, better air filtration, and probably equally reliable.
Both run a .325, but I would NEVER put more than a 16" on a 260.
I have run an 18" on a 346 and it runs fine.
I had to get both, and like em both, but if you HAVE to have one, the 346 is more versatile and just FUN.
That being said, the 346 is the all around better performer.
Its not even debatable.
Less vibes, faster cutter, more powerful, better air filtration, and probably equally reliable.
Both run a .325, but I would NEVER put more than a 16" on a 260.
I have run an 18" on a 346 and it runs fine.
I had to get both, and like em both, but if you HAVE to have one, the 346 is more versatile and just FUN.
Monkeyhanger
ArboristSite Guru
Hi,
I've used both and the 346XP beats the 260 just about every way possible except for the 346XP having a narrow powerband and likely less torque (not that it matters much for a limbing saw).
In general for me the saw buying rule is small saws = Husqvarna and big saws = Stihl.
Bye
I've used both and the 346XP beats the 260 just about every way possible except for the 346XP having a narrow powerband and likely less torque (not that it matters much for a limbing saw).
In general for me the saw buying rule is small saws = Husqvarna and big saws = Stihl.
Bye
Last edited:
