Testing chainsaw protective pants?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
timberrat

timberrat

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
152
Location
oregon
poor ham

poor pigy. seriously this video reminds me of the not so smart guy i put in body bag a few years back. the fire wood cutter i put in the body bag cut the femoral artery . the saw bound in in a limb and came full force right threw his right thigh. let just say shredded meat special from the saw chain contact. SO WEAR THE BEST CHAPS YOU CAN BUY :bowdown:
 
Bremen

Bremen

ArboristSite Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2003
Messages
87
Location
Buffalo NY, USA
aquan8tor said:
sorry, let me rephrase that. In the link I posted, the chaps tested said labonville on them, I think. I could be wrong. I thought each chap tested had a ham under it to simulate human tissue.

Ah, yes that makes sense. In that video (where they state it's a ham) I wouldn't want to be wearing those green chaps, not a nice ending at all. Ouch! The labonville chaps they test seemed to do a fine job.

In the other video, from labonville's site, they don't state what's under the chaps but it looked like it might be leg-sized round of wood. None of the chaps in that video did *too* badly IMO, but why not get the best.
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
I finally got it to work, saving it like you said. I was trying to open it with WMP before. Quicktime worked fine. I'm a little worried about my chaps now, though........don't know who makes them. I'll be calling tomorrow to speak to someone about it. I want my money back!!!
 
Like The Woods!

Like The Woods!

ArboristSite Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2005
Messages
72
Location
Middle of the Great State of Maine
Don't cut when tired...

In over thirty years I have only once had a mishap. Many years ago I cut into the toe portion of a pair of safety boots. They did protect my foot.

Then...two years ago I purchased my first pair of chaps. Have nipped them twice in almost the same place, (left thigh). Both times it was when I was tired...OH :censored: !

Both times they stopped the chain before it bit my leg.:)
 
Freakingstang

Freakingstang

Doctor Freakinstein
Joined
Dec 23, 2005
Messages
5,648
Location
NE Ohio
I think some of you are "freaking" out.

Yes, they did cut through...Watch the video again. There is a nick in the undersides of all the other ones..

They did their job. You would have a cut on your leg that was not deep and probably would not require stiches.

Now, try that test with jeans..You lost your leg, or bled out. Either way=not good.

Yeah the chaps got cut, but they stopped the saw with minimal injuries...Did just what they are designed to.

Besides, you gotta do a lot to take a full bar shot to the leg like that Ham did....

Just food for thought, no pissing matches needed (or intended).

Be safe
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
Freakingstang said:
I think some of you are "freaking" out.

Yes, they did cut through...Watch the video again. There is a nick in the undersides of all the other ones..

They did their job. You would have a cut on your leg that was not deep and probably would not require stiches.

Now, try that test with jeans..You lost your leg, or bled out. Either way=not good.

Yeah the chaps got cut, but they stopped the saw with minimal injuries...Did just what they are designed to.

Besides, you gotta do a lot to take a full bar shot to the leg like that Ham did....

Just food for thought, no pissing matches needed (or intended).

Be safe


wasn't trying to get in a match, although I have a habit of letting my redhead temper get into my debates from time to time...... :angry: :sword:

I think I'll keep the chaps I have, since they're already broken in with lots of sweat, a little (unrelated) blood, and some tears (maybe, but I won't admit it in person).
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
Don't know. They weren't part of either test. FWIW, there are several companies that sell green safety chaps, however. And, they're all similar color green. In the video where the chaps were cut clean through, they mentioned they were several years old. Perhaps this plays a factor into how well they stop the chain--how well they separate from the rest of the fabric matrix based on how compacted the fibers are, how oil soaked maybe, I don't know. I'm not a ballistic fiber expert. Maybe someone else will chime in here who is an engineer.
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
also, I just noticed that the pants in question are the only ones other than the labonville 6ply chaps that are Class "A" rated. All the other chaps that I see from Bailey's are class B. Don't know what that means. I'm not saying any chaps are better than others, no matter whether they are green chaps from Bailey's, green chaps from Labonville, green chaps from joe schmoe...I just read the fine print at the bottom of the pictures....
 
musch

musch

Chainsaw Zombie
Joined
Jul 26, 2006
Messages
885
Location
Wisconsin
I wonder if that 2 layer kevlar is a misprint.
It says this. Meets BNQ/CUL Class A standards CAN-BNQ 1923-450-M91 and U.L Approved.

And I'll tell ya they are thick and heavy.

:help:
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
I think I just figured out the class A/B ratings. The pants and the labonville chaps have protection on the back of the calf all the way to the ankle. I could be wrong, and haven't read any OSHA or UL ratings, so DON'T QUOTE ME on that one! :) as for what happened with timberrat's buddy, that is really horrible. I'm so sorry. My father years ago cut into the tip of his boot when cutting firewood from a kickback. I think that was the day he got rid of the little red homelite superEZ for a stihl with quickstop. I wear steel toe boots; I should get kevlar, but I'm pretty careful and I'm not cutting much firewood this year.
 
maveric944

maveric944

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Oct 30, 2006
Messages
110
Location
South Yorkshire. UK
i'm glad i didn't see the video before i got my first saw, i might have bought a gas fire instead. i always give my saw respect when i'm using it , but i think now i'll call it "SIR" as well.

mav
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
Nice avatar, considering the subject matter. I'm far less experienced than most here, but I definitely give my saw the respect it commands when cutting anything.


Sidenote edit: gas fires suck. Dad just took out the woodstove for an LP insert this year. It doesn't get anywhere close to as warm as the JOTUL with a catalytic converter on it. You couldn't sit within 10 feet of that thing when it was really cranking.
 

blis

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
1,512
Location
Finland
aquan8tor said:
I think I just figured out the class A/B ratings. The pants and the labonville chaps have protection on the back of the calf all the way to the ankle. I could be wrong, and haven't read any OSHA or UL ratings, so DON'T QUOTE ME on that one! :) as for what happened with timberrat's buddy, that is really horrible. I'm so sorry. My father years ago cut into the tip of his boot when cutting firewood from a kickback. I think that was the day he got rid of the little red homelite superEZ for a stihl with quickstop. I wear steel toe boots; I should get kevlar, but I'm pretty careful and I'm not cutting much firewood this year.

dont worry, steeltoed boots are plenty, no need to get kevlar ones...

oh btw, i believe that the a/b/(c?) rating means the chainspeed its certed to if i remember right...
 
smokechase II

smokechase II

Addicted to ArboristSite
Joined
Sep 11, 2005
Messages
3,644
Location
oregon
chaps testing

A few thoughts on chaps.

The video states at the start that these are field tests only.
To do a proper testing a device must be made that will apply consistent pressure and chain speed. Chains resharpened in between each test and so forth. {The video showed at least a respectable 12,200 rpm's}

How you sharpen your saw and what type of chain you run are also big deals.

Please note that no chap manufacturer has ever guaranteed their product to stop a saw. View your chaps as a great idea, like a seat belt - air bags - hard hat, but by no means a guarantee. Wear them always, but always have a functioning chain brake and always watch that tip and your thumbs etc.

Yes, with any cut that cuts more than a strand or two of the protective fabric, the chaps must be retired. A great use you can give those retired chaps is to finish your tailgate safety with a demo. Attach the old chaps to a log and have your best sawyer lay into them.

One thing you may note is that if you fasten the chaps loosely, the saw will rotate them exposing unprotected log(leg). So if an operator is not wearing a full leg, (360 degree coverage), the fastening of chaps snuggly is critical.

Additionally no repair can be made that sews through the chaps layers. If the layers are held down and not allowed to float freely, the can be cut through easily and are less likely to hold together long enough to jam a sprocket.
Dirty chaps are also a problem. If you have chaps that are soaked in bar oil/grease, be aware that will also hold together the fabric similar to sewing and they are cut through easier in testing.
But don't clean with a detergent with chlorine. Chlorine weakens Kevlar badly.

Now having said all that. The heavier first pair of Labonville chaps sure look like something I'd want on my newer employees. If not everyone.
 
aquan8tor

aquan8tor

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
911
Location
Charlottesville/Crozet area, Virginia
smokechase II said:
A few thoughts on chaps.

The video states at the start that these are field tests only.
To do a proper testing a device must be made that will apply consistent pressure and chain speed. Chains resharpened in between each test and so forth. {The video showed at least a respectable 12,200 rpm's}

How you sharpen your saw and what type of chain you run are also big deals.

Please note that no chap manufacturer has ever guaranteed their product to stop a saw. View your chaps as a great idea, like a seat belt - air bags - hard hat, but by no means a guarantee. Wear them always, but always have a functioning chain brake and always watch that tip and your thumbs etc.

Yes, with any cut that cuts more than a strand or two of the protective fabric, the chaps must be retired. A great use you can give those retired chaps is to finish your tailgate safety with a demo. Attach the old chaps to a log and have your best sawyer lay into them.

One thing you may note is that if you fasten the chaps loosely, the saw will rotate them exposing unprotected log(leg). So if an operator is not wearing a full leg, (360 degree coverage), the fastening of chaps snuggly is critical.

Additionally no repair can be made that sews through the chaps layers. If the layers are held down and not allowed to float freely, the can be cut through easily and are less likely to hold together long enough to jam a sprocket.
Dirty chaps are also a problem. If you have chaps that are soaked in bar oil/grease, be aware that will also hold together the fabric similar to sewing and they are cut through easier in testing.
But don't clean with a detergent with chlorine. Chlorine weakens Kevlar badly.

Now having said all that. The heavier first pair of Labonville chaps sure look like something I'd want on my newer employees. If not everyone.



Learned more in your post than in either video, or listening to dad for years telling me about chainsaw injuries he saw in med school.
 

Latest posts

Top