Rate your Chinese chain saw?

Arborist Forum

Help Support Arborist Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Maine_woodburner

Maine_woodburner

ArboristSite Lurker
Joined
Aug 11, 2022
Messages
16
Location
New Sweden
2nd tank I am assuming the capture on the sprocket came off and the clutch exploded on my G466. MS460 clone.
Mangled from the grub screw up and the brake spring. Going to either get or order MS460 parts from the dealer.
1st tank with a 25 inch bar, so much better than my 50 or 40 cc saws, Husqvarna 450 rancher 20" and Efco MTS4000 with a 16.
Hopefully make enough wood with this saw to sell and get a name brand. It is a process and I can only afford what I can afford.
Also will contact the seller and see about replacement parts coming out. Also see the chain tension adjustment as a possible purchase tomorrow.
 

Attachments

  • 20220910_195008.jpg
    20220910_195008.jpg
    1.9 MB · Views: 0
  • 20220910_194957.jpg
    20220910_194957.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 0
K-techcowboy

K-techcowboy

N.A.O.T Racing
Joined
Oct 27, 2021
Messages
357
Location
Oklahoma
which saws are we talking about here, I mean these days which saws aren't made it china? all the big players have plants there, unfortunately that's just how it is theses days the only thing important is how cheap things can be made.
Echo is in Japan thats at least a step up from China and im really liking my 7310pw and my 3510 is my go to limber vs the ms250c i was using. Im about to start looking at timing numbers on the 7310 cause it feels like its got hidden power somewhere. Torque is awsome
 
Marcus James

Marcus James

ArboristSite Lurker
Joined
Jan 20, 2021
Messages
18
Location
MI
Echo is in Japan thats at least a step up from China and im really liking my 7310pw and my 3510 is my go to limber vs the ms250c i was using. Im about to start looking at timing numbers on the 7310 cause it feels like its got hidden power somewhere. Torque is awsome
My Echo 620 p is wonderful! 2 years now and not a single complaint other than the fact it's got a somewhat difficult to get to spark plug, a silly on/off switch and it's not as sexy looking as a Stihl. Good, solid, simple saw that's durable and powerful enough for most cutting. Had to get used to it flooding if I tried to start it with the dang thing turned off. Learned my lesson.
 
Hermio

Hermio

ArboristSite Guru
Joined
Oct 25, 2015
Messages
670
Location
45113
which saws are we talking about here, I mean these days which saws aren't made it china? all the big players have plants there, unfortunately that's just how it is theses days the only thing important is how cheap things can be made.
"Made in China" does not always mean it is crap. It depends on the brand and the company. "Made in Japan" used to mean junk. Not anymore. I believe if the major name brands set up shop there, they will have sufficient Q/C measures to make the product just as good as in any other country. However, most Chinese domestic brands lag behind Western brands, with a few exceptions.
 
biggerstaff94

biggerstaff94

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jul 21, 2022
Messages
117
Location
NE Indiana
On a scale of 1-10 i give my G660 a solid 8. Ive had to throw some parts at it that probably wouldn’t have been an issue on a Stihl but im still well under half the cost of a MS661. Been tuned to 13,500rpm and has happily cut there for years. Recently picked up a 32” b/c, used to run a 28” on it, it doesnt even notice a difference power wise.
A1851356-92FE-4559-8D16-ADD8315749FF.jpeg
 
Maine_woodburner

Maine_woodburner

ArboristSite Lurker
Joined
Aug 11, 2022
Messages
16
Location
New Sweden
This is the Holzfforma g466 with 25 inch bar and chain.
Seller responded fast, let's see if the parts come and it works properly. Might get some sthil parts next payday, but working the wood for money to afford a real sthil.

2nd tank I am assuming the capture on the sprocket came off and the clutch exploded on my G466. MS460 clone.
Mangled from the grub screw up and the brake spring. Going to either get or order MS460 parts from the dealer.
1st tank with a 25 inch bar, so much better than my 50 or 40 cc saws, Husqvarna 450 rancher 20" and Efco MTS4000 with a 16.
Hopefully make enough wood with this saw to sell and get a name brand. It is a process and I can only afford what I can afford.
Also will contact the seller and see about replacement parts coming out. Also see the chain tension adjustment as a possible purchase tomorrow.
 
Bubster

Bubster

ArboristSite Guru
AS Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2021
Messages
815
Location
WV
I ordered my Chinese clone G372 back in late July and by mid-August I cancelled the order because it never arrived. Some supply issues they said.I guess it was for the best as I was very leary of ordering one to begin with. But looking at YT videos, some seem very happy with them.
 
a. palmer jr.
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
Messages
15,253
Location
Southern Indiana
I ordered my Chinese clone G372 back in late July and by mid-August I cancelled the order because it never arrived. Some supply issues they said.I guess it was for the best as I was very leary of ordering one to begin with. But looking at YT videos, some seem very happy with them.
You must have ordered from Huztl. I've had parts ordered from them and by the time I received them I'd forgotten I ordered them.
 
Captain Bruce
Joined
Apr 5, 2015
Messages
936
Location
Michigan
which saws are we talking about here, I mean these days which saws aren't made it china? all the big players have plants there, unfortunately that's just how it is theses days the only thing important is how cheap things can be made.
i DISAGREE. Plenty of excellent products are USA made. This question is, if you read it........rate your cheap piece of crap saw, knocked-off, by China. HUS, Farmtec, etc. Thats 100% chinesium garbage, constructed by children, next to multi-colored polluted rivers.......with a rice break mid-day.

Than again, only those who would stoop to spending their after-tax American dollars, on a genuine chinesium knock-off, to save money??? would be qualified to have an opinion.
 
Jake Wilson

Jake Wilson

ArboristSite Member
AS Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2017
Messages
50
Location
North central PA
On a scale of 1-10 i give my G660 a solid 8. Ive had to throw some parts at it that probably wouldn’t have been an issue on a Stihl but im still well under half the cost of a MS661. Been tuned to 13,500rpm and has happily cut there for years. Recently picked up a 32” b/c, used to run a 28” on it, it doesnt even notice a difference power wise.
View attachment 1016588
Curious - what parts?
 
biggerstaff94

biggerstaff94

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jul 21, 2022
Messages
117
Location
NE Indiana
Curious - what parts?
Chain tensioner, starter rope, oil pump, and it has all Stihl clutch parts.

The chain tensioner stripped and the starter rope broke within a couple months of me owning it. The oil pump turned out to just be clogged from the screen coming off but i put a new HO pump in anyway. The clutch springs got lazy so it got a new clutch. That was probably my fault. I rocked the chain and finished what i needed finished more than once lol.

I was pretty new to chainsaws when i bought this one so i made alot of the rookie mistakes and its lived so far.
 
thompsoncustom

thompsoncustom

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jul 13, 2022
Messages
450
Location
iowa
i DISAGREE. Plenty of excellent products are USA made. This question is, if you read it........rate your cheap piece of crap saw, knocked-off, by China. HUS, Farmtec, etc. Thats 100% chinesium garbage, constructed by children, next to multi-colored polluted rivers.......with a rice break mid-day.

Than again, only those who would stoop to spending their after-tax American dollars, on a genuine chinesium knock-off, to save money??? would be qualified to have an opinion.
Disagree with what? That most companies are doing there best to make things cheaper these days even if it's at the expense of quality?

I agree with you that there is some tools that are 100% USA made that are great but chainsaws aren't one of them. there is no 100% USA made chainsaw that I know of. maybe there's a small company out there somewhere.

Buy American Act at 41 U.S.C. says to put MADE IN THE USA it only has to be 50% American made.

so the question is your saw 100% chinesium or 50% chinesium.
 
serdie

serdie

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jan 19, 2021
Messages
170
Location
W.Va.
I ordered through Amazon,but who knows who they get them through.
I have 2 chink saws. 1 is a G372, the other, a G288. Both have the crap beat out of em by my guys, replaced carb on 372, replaced the starter rope and oil pump on the 288. They have run almost a year now and I have to give em a 8. I also have the equivalent saws in Husqvarna, the chink saws once broke in run almost neck and neck with em. Just sayin
 
biggerstaff94

biggerstaff94

ArboristSite Operative
Joined
Jul 21, 2022
Messages
117
Location
NE Indiana
i DISAGREE. Plenty of excellent products are USA made. This question is, if you read it........rate your cheap piece of crap saw, knocked-off, by China. HUS, Farmtec, etc. Thats 100% chinesium garbage, constructed by children, next to multi-colored polluted rivers.......with a rice break mid-day.

Than again, only those who would stoop to spending their after-tax American dollars, on a genuine chinesium knock-off, to save money??? would be qualified to have an opinion.
Ever ran one for any amount of time? Just curious.
 

Latest posts

Top